Showing posts with label Russian Orthodox Church. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Russian Orthodox Church. Show all posts

Friday, 11 September 2015

Russia and the West have swapped Spiritual and Cultural Roles

0 Comments
Powerful insights from a Danish theologian and journalist on the spiritual collapse of the post-Christian West and the resurgence of Orthodox Christian Russia, with its renewed love of God, its "poetic and cultured people", and its "fantastic energy, a moral energy":
"The situation in the West is the complete opposite [from that in Russia]. We celebrate death and have surrendered to the satanic view of man in a self-righteous rage and rant against God... We favour euthanasia, abortion on demand, homosexual rights and same-sex marriage while our cities are submerged in Islam and growing segregation."

Russia and the West have swapped Spiritual and Cultural Roles
Interview with Iben Thranholm
Russia Insider � September 7, 2015

The subject of this interview is a Danish journalist and theologian who hosted a series of five programmes, entitled �From Russia with Love� on Danish national public service radio, Radio24syv, with the sub-heading �An Unbiased Look at Putin's Russia.�


Thranholm on a recent trip to Russia

Inspired by Emperor Constantine, she believes Christianity in the West can be rejuvenated by looking to the East. Iben is aware of the sheer enormity of this task. �Such, alas, is the depth to which Western hatred for Christianity has sunk,� says the theologian, who does not hesitate to defend President Putin, on whom the Western media delights in heaping derision and scorn.

�The Pussy Riot case opened the door to Russia for me,� she explains.   

�I understood that Russia is a country that refuses to compromise on Christian values. Russia is not just a country or a nation, Russia is a spiritual concept, a state of mind. Criticism of President Putin was not the crime for which the activists were tried and convicted. Their crime was the invasion of the Christ-The-Saviour Cathedral, the holiest of places, and engaging in a blasphemous act in front of the iconostases.

�They are familiar with the bitter fruit of atheism and have no appetite for the bleak and barren wasteland it produced.�

"In the West, freedom of speech is widely deployed for the purpose of desecrating religion, but Russia does not permit crossing the line into blasphemy. That really fascinated me, and so I travelled to Moscow to learn more and this eventually resulted in a series of radio programmes trying to help Danes move beyond the tedious and unhelpful caricature-like clich�s and provide them with a nuanced view of Russia.�


Russia: Tens of thousands in Cross Procession in Honor of the 700th Anniversary of St. Sergius of Radonezh

Q�What was your impression of Russia?    

�I experienced a fantastic energy, a moral energy similar to America in the '50s with the old moral values. I met helpful, poetic and cultured people with a spirit of self-sacrifice I have not seen before. The atmosphere in Moscow is completely different from that of any capital in Europe, and unlike here in the West, I feel much more spiritually free in the East.   

"While the West is deriding and disowning Christianity and Europe revels in self-loathing, Russians are returning to Christianity in a modern and contemporary context. Bear in mind that Christianity was suppressed under Communism, which was atheistic. Russians are familiar with the bitter fruit of atheism and have no appetite for the bleak and barren wasteland it produced.

�The young, the hip, the wise and the wealthy, express their Christianity as a completely natural and straightforward thing...�

"The interesting thing is, that in Russia, Christianity is associated with being modern and progressive. It is the spirit of the young, the hip, the wise and the wealthy, who express their Christianity as a completely natural and straightforward way of life. Christianity is simply fashionable, but not in the superficial Western pop manner. Christianity�s roots grow deep in the soil of Russian life, and they look with amazement at how we guard, or rather, disregard, our spiritual heritage.

"Not only that: They discern in our obsession with political correctness, and the social liberal opinion policing of the general media and academia, a new manifestation of the terror of totalitarianism they counted themselves blessed to escape after 75 terrible years.

"After the Cold War, East and West swapped roles spiritually, culturally and morally. Cultural Marxism now holds unrestrained sway in the West."

Q�But Communism and Social Democracy are probably not the same?

�Let me put it a different way. During the rule of Communism, Russia found itself in the grip of a culture of death, but she is returning to life, in the sense of Christian culture with a strong awareness of the historical roots and continuity.�  

"The situation in the West is the complete opposite. We celebrate death and have surrendered to the satanic view of man in a self-righteous rage and rant against God. We can divorce with ease on-line. We prioritise work and career above family responsibilities especially raising children. We favour euthanasia, abortion on demand, homosexual rights and same-sex marriage while our cities are submerged in Islam and growing segregation."

�Russians perceive activists like Pussy Riot as latter-day Bolsheviks�

"Russia has chosen a completely different direction, and it is one of the reasons that many Russians perceive activists like Pussy Riot as latter-day Bolsheviks. They invade and desecrate the sanctity of the church, a holy place. The West celebrates this as progress and prosperity. Russians are reminded that the spirit of communism is still alive. It merely assumes new forms and takes up residence in the West, where liberals and progressives love and adore Pussy Riot.

"Today, the spirit of communism shows itself in western worship of human rights, freedom of speech and the elite�s utopian notions of so-called open societies. We are headed for the very wasteland that the Russians were relieved to leave behind. Patriarch Kirill has warned the West: 'Do not take the path we took. We tried it and it leads to destruction!'"   

Q�Recently the Russian military held an exercise based on the scenario of an attack on northern Norway, Aaland, Gotland and Bornholm. Do we just turn the other cheek?

�Well, that's not the true way to look at it. The Russians hold such an exercise because of the geopolitical pressure that NATO creates by deploying hostile military forces along the Ukrainian border and in the old Warsaw Pact countries.

"Russian foreign policy has long been demonized. Russia is compelled to respond to a situation it did not create, which is not the same as aggression. Why should Russia accept being cut off from access to the sea, from Saint Petersburg to Vladivostok? Such a thing is unthinkable.

"With bald-faced hypocrisy, the West makes it look like Russia is our new enemy. The truth is exactly the opposite. The West is its own worst enemy."


Thursday, 25 June 2015

Fr. Daniel Byantoro and the Future of Orthodoxy in Indonesia

0 Comments
"Despite the presence of Islam in Indonesia, there is great hope for Orthodoxy there... We are seeing in the world today a rising culture of hatred and death, and the only way to defeat it is with the culture of love and life�that is, the culture of the Gospel, the culture of Orthodoxy."

See also these feature articles:


via 'I Believe in the Future of Orthodoxy in Indonesia' � A Conversation with Archimandrite Daniel (Byantoro)
Pravoslavie � June 23, 2015 (Thanks to Bill)

Fr. Daniel at Sretensky Monastery, Moscow
On Monday June 15, Archimandrite Daniel Byantoro arrived in Moscow with his fellow priest Fr. Alexios. Fr. Daniel is the first Indonesian convert to Orthodoxy and the founder and heart of the struggling Orthodox Church there. He came to Russia for several days to visit holy sites, hierarchs and friends, and to spread the word of his mission to his spiritual brothers and sisters in Russia. On Wednesday he sat down for an interview with Pravoslavie.ru in which he spoke about his country and its Christian history.

At a public lecture the night before given at the Fund of Slavic Culture Fr. Daniel spoke more about his own conversion experience. Raised in an entirely Islamic village, all that he knew of Christianity came from the Koran: as Christians worship three Gods, turned a prophet into God and made God weak, unable to save His prophet from crucifixion, they are going to hell. Islam denies that Christ is the Son of God; they deny the Trinity as well as the crucifixion and resurrection of Christ, and therefore, as Fr. Daniel noted, they deny the entirety of Christian teaching (see Koran 5:72, 73, 98:6 which Fr. Daniel referenced easily from memory).


According to Islamic belief, all the prophets from Adam to Christ were Muslims�Judaism and Christianity are but deviations from the pure religion of Islam. And what�s more, as Fr. Daniel expounded the night before over dinner, Muslims believe that everything in creation is naturally Muslim, submitting to the will of God. Apart from any outside influences everyone would naturally grow up to worship the God of the Muslims. Orthodox Christianity also teaches that human will naturally finds its telos in Christ, although we inherit a fallen mode of human nature. Conversely, Islam teaches that to leave the religion is to wholly forfeit your human nature�that is, Christians, Jews, and others are not human, and therefore it is permissible to deceive and terribly abuse them when expedient and for the desired end of their conversion. As Fr. Daniel emphasized, these are two competing systems�both cannot be true. We are called to make a firm decision and be educated in our decision to lead others to true human fulfillment in Christ.

Given this education he had no interest in Christianity, but questions about God remained with him. Islam is wholly iconoclastic; God cannot be imagined, and local Muslim clerics could not explain to him who is God, nor could the first Christian he met in high school explain the Trinity. His search continued until one night, in the midst of his evening prayers, he beheld a vision of light in the form of a man. He heard a voice in the depths of his being which said �if you want to be saved, follow Me.� When it happened again the next night he asked the identity of this vision. He shuddered at the answer: �Jesus Christ.� He was confused and disturbed�why, while worshiping as a Muslim, had he seen Christ, and not Mohammed? Again the third night Christ appeared to him, proclaiming that salvation has nothing to do with Mohammed but is found only in following Him.

Understandably, Fr. Daniel was confused�he believed what he had been taught, and he believed what he had seen. He fasted and prayed, and opening the Koran, his eyes fell on a passage that led to his conversion to Christ. Koran 3:45 speaks of the Annunciation to the Virgin Mary, referring to Jesus as the �Word� of God. Contemplating this verse he had read so many times, Fr. Daniel realized: 

Man�s word comes out of his mouth but originates in his mind. This means man�s word is one with him, and if Jesus is God�s Word then He is one with God. The Word and the Speaker are one. But what of the Spirit? Man can only speak while living, and man lives because he has a spirit. Man�s spirit is within him, and thus his word and spirit are within him. Therefore God�s Word and Spirit are also within Him, and the God of the Christians is One. But why is the Word of God also called the Son of God? The Word resides within the mind, so the mind is pregnant with the word, and the mouth gives birth to the word, so the word is the child of the mind. Thus, if Jesus is the Word of God then He is also the Son of God. To have a Son God does not need a wife, for what is meant by Son is Word.

He further understood that among humans we cannot know each other without words, and so man can only know God by His Word. According even to the Koran the Word of God is Jesus, and therefore to know God He must know Christ. That night Fr. Daniel became a Christian.

Fr. Daniel became a Protestant, although he was confused by the multitude of denominations. He wanted the one, pure teaching of Christ that he knew from the Scriptures. In 1979 he began seminary studies in South Korea but his heart remained restless, until, in his final year, he happened upon an English copy of The Orthodox Church by Metropolitan Kallistos Ware. As have so many over the years since it was written, he found the unwavering Church of Jesus Christ for which his heart had been yearning since his conversion, and he soon learned that not far from his dormitory was located an Orthodox Church. His heart was home. On September 6, 1983, he became the first and only Orthodox Christian from Indonesia. From Korea he traveled to Greece, spending 10 months on Mount Athos where he became acquainted with the holy elder Emelianos. He then traveled to America where he was ordained to the priesthood in 1987.

On June 6, 1988 he returned home to Indonesia to found the Indonesian Orthodox Church. In 1989 he baptized the first convert�a young Muslim man, and in 1996 he founded Indonesia�s first Orthodox Church�the Holy Trinity parish in the city of Solo in the center of Java. Since then, by the grace of God, the mission has been slowly but steadily growing. Today there are 2,000 Orthodox Christians in 30 parishes and mission outposts, served by 14 priests (and four more have already reposed in the Lord). All converts are brought into the Church by the one Christian baptism regardless of their religious background.

Fr. Daniel believes that, despite the presence of Islam in Indonesia, there is great hope for Orthodoxy there. He hopes and believes that Indonesia will one day be an Orthodox country, and he looks to his spiritual brothers and sisters in Russia, who have endured and been strengthened by unspeakable suffering, to be a support for the struggling mission in Indonesia. Fr. Daniel called upon all Russians to once again become missionary beacons to the world and bring the light of Christ to all. He finished his remarks by emphasizing that we are seeing in the world today a rising culture of hatred and death, and the only way to defeat it is with the culture of love and life�that is, the culture of the Gospel, the culture of Orthodoxy, the culture that formed Russian 1,000 years ago. This culture, Fr. Daniel believes, does not need to be defended, but speaks for itself as the truth.

Fr. Daniel told Pravoslavie.ru more about the history and current state of the Orthodox mission in Indonesia:    

�Father, tell us about your trip. What brought you to Russia?

I came to Russia at the invitation of the committee for the celebration of the anniversary of the canonization of St. John of Kronstadt, and I also came to meet with our Russian hierarchs to discuss the status and needs of our mission in Indonesia. I wanted to meet with His Holiness Patriarch Kirill, but that was not possible. I did meet with Metropolitan Hilarion Alfeyev, and with Archbishop Mark of Yegorievsk, and I was very satisfied with these meetings. I say that it is a miracle of God, because even without planning I was able to see the both of them. Secondly, I came to Moscow at the invitation of a group of laypeople who are the spiritual children of Fr. Matthew from Siberia. Last year they visited Indonesia, so they know our churches. They were searching for evidence of St. Matthew�s travels to Indonesia. They believe that St. Matthew visited that land. I went with them to the place, on the island of Sumatra, in the village of Barus. I see in our meeting in Indonesia the Providence of God, because then by invitation from St. Petersburg I was able to come to Moscow. I have been praying for this. So, I see that this is God�s Providence. And it�s no small miracle for me.

�Tell us a little bit about Indonesia as a country.

�Indonesia is an open country that has a lot of influence from cultures from all over the world. Indonesia does not have one culture�we consist of so many different races and ethnicities. We have nearly 700 languages and dialects. They are not spoken by people coming from outside, but by Indonesians. So, we have the yellow race, the brown race, Eurasian�a mix of Asian and European�and we have black people. Indonesia consists of over 17,000 islands. There are five main, large islands: Sumatra, Java, Kalimantan or Borneo, Sulawesi, and Papua. And the most famous island is of course Bali�everybody knows that one.

Historically, Indonesian people, especially western Indonesians, came from South China 5,000 years ago. And the black people may have come from Africa by raft, also around 5,000 years ago. At that time, people were animists or shamanists. At the beginning of the first century we began to have Hindu and Buddhist kingdoms. The largest Buddhist kingdom we had was in the seventh century, called the Kingdom of Srivijaya. The largest and last Hindu kingdom was in the thirteenth century, called the Kingdom of Majapahit, which is my hometown. Islam arrived in the fifteenth century. This Hindu kingdom was destroyed, and Islamic kingdoms began to rule the country, up to today. 

The Dutch came to Indonesia in the sixteenth century; the Portuguese first came to Indonesia, but they were unable to stay for long because they were kicked out by the Dutch. The Dutch were unable to rule all of Indonesia but only different parts of the islands. Their rule lasted 350 years.

On October 28, 1928, an educated young Indonesian felt the need to unite our country against the Dutch, who had chopped up our country. Then we adopted the Malay language as our national language. It is similar to the language spoken in Malaysia but it developed differently. So at that time we recognized one Indonesian language, one country that consists of so many different islands and so many different ethnicities, tribes, and races. 

Our young people continued to fight the Dutch. On August 17, 1945 we were able to get our independence�it was not given but we fought for our independence. The first president was Mr. Sukarno, and he was the close friend of the Russian President Brezhnev. 

From 1945 until the 1960�s, Indonesia and Russia were in a very close relationship. In 1965 there was an attempted coup by the Communist party of Indonesia. But then there was a big massacre�more than two million Indonesians were massacred, by their own people, especially by the Muslim party. It was horrendous. 

Then President Sukarno was put under house arrest, and his general, Mr. Suharto, became dictator of Indonesia. International people called him a benevolent dictator. He was president for thirty-three years, after which he was toppled by a student demonstration in 1998. 

Then there was another disaster�the rape and looting of the Indonesian Chinese. It was another horrendous situation. After that we had an election, and since then we have had elections regularly; now we have our sixth president, and the country is a democratic republic.

�When did Christianity come to Indonesia?

�Christianity has deep roots in Indonesia, although they are thin. According to available documents, in the seventh century, before Islam came to Indonesia, there were Syriac Christian people in Indonesia, even during the kingdoms of Srivijaya and Majapahit. We do not know exactly whether they were Nestorian, Monophysite, or Syriac Byzantine. 

In the eleventh century there was an envoy from the Pope of Rome�a priest who visited Beijing, stopped over in Indonesia, and met with ten native Indonesian Christians. Presumably they were the remnant of those ancient Christians. And this Roman Catholic priest (possibly the Churches were not yet separated), according to this document, gave Communion to those Indonesian Christians. After that we do not hear any stories of Christianity in Indonesia. 

Later, a Roman priest visited the kingdom of Majapahit, but again there are no further histories. Christianity in the form of Roman Catholicism and Protestantism came to Indonesia through the Dutch and the Portuguese in the sixteenth century. 

While the Dutch were still in Indonesia, there were Armenian and Russian Christians. The Russians presumably came to Indonesia together with St. John of Shanghai. When they left China for the Philippines, some of them went to Indonesia, and then Archbishop John went to San Francisco. Those Russian people had two churches at that time�the church of St. John the Baptist in the city of Jakarta, as I was told (of course it is no longer there), and another in the city of Bandung. But during the massacre of 1965 these people fled Indonesia, so there is no trace of the Armenian or Russian people in Indonesia anymore. 

Thus, Orthodox Christianity came back to Indonesia when I started the mission. It will definitely stay in Indonesia, because I am not an immigrant or a foreigner. I am a son of the land. Spiritual Russia returned later.

�Could you tell us about the modern situation of Orthodox Christians in Indonesia.

�Of course the situation of the Orthodox Church in Indonesia is still weak, because we do not receive any help from anywhere, and financially I have to work hard to be able to sustain the mission. From time to time I go to America to raise funds, but they are not sufficient to help all the priests or even to obtain the things we need. I have to work, teaching at the university and giving seminars. I am invited to preach in non-Orthodox churches, because I need the money. With the money I save through my work, sometimes through gifts from non-Orthodox friends, I buy land and build simple churches on it. I also help the priests from time to time�sometimes with schooling their children, when their wives are sick, and many other things. It is fortunate that I�m not married; otherwise my wife would get angry with me because I have nothing! Whatever I get I use to help others. For two years I was helped by the Moscow Patriarchate�it has not been cut off completely. Not all of our priests were getting a share, so I gave what was given to me. I distributed to those priests who did not receive anything, so that I was left with nothing.

Now the Church is still growing in spite of these dire needs and difficulties. I give seminars in different cities and places in Indonesia to open new communities of Orthodox converts. With that the need to buy more land and build more churches is increasing. Now I am coming to a point where I cannot do it myself. I am getting older. My body does not cooperate with my zeal inside. The zeal does not subside�I still feel young inside, but my body cannot pretend that it is still young. My biggest desire is to build a monastery, because when I am not able to do anything then I need to go the monastery and start monastic life. With the small savings that I had I was able to buy a piece of land�2,000 square meters I think. So I bought the land already, but I was not able to continue building because I did not have enough money to build the monastery. Therefore, I appeal to anyone who is interested in helping to build a monastery. I am willing to name the monastery after the patron saint of the person who contributes�or however they want it to be named.

Another thing I want is to have a seminary, because it is important for people to be educated within the context of their own country and culture. The sense of the impending time to leave this world is very strong within me. The sense that God will call me home is very strong. I hope it is not soon, but you cannot tell. So that is why I need more young people to come along, to continue the efforts of the mission. I need to send students to study theology, hopefully in Russia, to replace me and Fr. Alexis when we are gone.

I think another urgent need that we have now concerns the first-built Orthodox Church in Indonesia in the city of Solo, in the center of Java, where Fr. Alexis is pastor. I bought that land. At first I rented the land from a Muslim cleric and then I was able to buy the land. In 1996 we bought the Holy Trinity church�the first ever Orthodox Church in Indonesia. And then I was able one-by-one to buy the other plots of land surrounding the church. This church was surrounded by Muslim neighbors. We were able to buy all this land around so that it could become our compound. However there are still four plots of land belonging to these Muslim neighbors, which we want to buy, so we can free the surrounding area to be the land belonging to the church. We need around $40,000 to free this land, and we are planning to build a wall around it to make it a historical landmark of our first Orthodox mission�so that when I die, our next generation will know that this is how Orthodoxy started.

Now we have altogether 2,000 people spread out all over Indonesia, with thirty churches and mission outposts, and it�s still growing. In Indonesia, any church or religion can operate only if it�s registered with the state. There are six religions recognized by the state. Islam is the majority of course, then Roman Catholicism, and then Protestantism, Hinduism, Buddhism, and Confucianism�the Chinese religion. These are the six recognized religions. We had a difficult time when we registered because we are not Roman Catholic and we are not Protestant. I was kicked around like a ball here and there. But through God�s grace and miracles the government was willing to accept us, and we were put in the Protestant department. They changed the name to the �Christian� department, because there are now non-Protestants in it! So our presence changed the law, in a way.

I have good relations with all other non-Orthodox Christian leaders, because I cannot afford to be at enmity with them in our minority status. We are a minority within a minority, so I can�t isolate myself from the others. We have worked together with Protestants many times�of course, without compromising the faith. I always wear my black robe and my cross when I am in an official meeting with them to show them that I am not Protestant. Basically, Indonesian people are very tolerant. It is because of their Hindu and Buddhist background. But there is growing influence from the Middle East, especially the Wahhabi type of Islam.* They create problems for us Christians. Many times they have destroyed churches, closed down churches, and in some areas they even kill Christians. We have difficulties with that. However I try very hard to have good relations with the Muslims�especially those who claim to be moderate.

[* Two nights prior to this interview, Fr. Daniel noted that, for example, over the past 15 years more women have begun wearing hijabs in Indonesia. He also commented that while Muslims in Russia tend to be more peaceful thanks to the influence of their Christian neighbors, now the Koran is available in Russian, and men being trained in Arabia are bringing a purer Islam. He worries that they will throw off their Christian influences and embrace a more violent, Koranic Islam.]


From time to time we have interfaith meetings, to discuss common concerns in the nation. However, I sometimes I feel wary, because what is on paper is not manifested on the ground. On paper of course we can be tolerant to one another, but on the ground they have many times burned our churches. So, I do not know which face of Islam I should believe. Also, the government has a law that if any Christians want to build a church, you must have at least ninety members from your area, and you must have sixty signatures from surrounding Muslim neighbors. To get two signatures is lucky�to get sixty is nearly impossible. Therefore, we have to try in different ways to get this permission�usually through diplomacy and connections. Sometimes we can prevail, many times not. But with God�s miracles, everything is possible.

Recently, I was invited to a radical Muslim madrasa�an Islamic boarding school. It has 6,000 students. They are planning to make an Islamic country out of Indonesia. I was surprised that I was invited to explain the Trinity in that place. Of course with them I had to use the primary sources�the Hebrew, the Greek, and the Arabic. By God�s grace I know those three languages. I also used the pattern of Islamic theological thought to explain to them. I was perhaps the first Christian clergyman to talk in that situation. When we went there, forty-five Protestant pastors escorted me, because they wanted to know what would happen. We went by bus, together. They wanted to protect me also�that is the fruit of my friendship with them. 

So to my surprise, after I finished my lecture, these Muslim clerics�one or two hundred of them, maybe more�gave me a long, standing ovation. They came to shake my hand, to embrace me, thanking me for explaining the Trinity in a way they understood. And they told the people that we have a guest of another religion, but it should not be another religion because they believe in one God! So that is an example of how I communicate with the Muslims. I do not take a confrontational approach, but one of friendship and dialogue.

The members of the Indonesian Church vary. A few of them are rich people�some are educated, many are not. Many are poor.

�How do you arrange the liturgical life of the parishes?

�In the past, when I started the mission in Solo, we had Liturgy every day, early in the morning; but eventually it turned out to be impractical for people who have to work. Especially now in the big cities, where traffic jams are so horrendous�as in Jakarta�and not many people have their own cars, it is impossible to have a regular liturgical life. It is impossible to have weekday worship. Usually we have only Saturday Vespers and Sunday Liturgy. Confession is heard either on Saturday or on Sunday during the Liturgy. We emphasize long preaching, because the people need teaching more than anything else. It is my belief that the Bible should be an open book for the people, so that�s why I conduct a lot Bible study. Sometimes it�s topical Bible study, according to dogma, or book study, like the Letter to the Romans, verse-by-verse, word-by-word. I want my people to be Biblically literate. If not, Indonesian people can be very superstitious. If there is no Biblical information, I�m afraid they�ll understand our ceremonies superstitiously. That is why Liturgy and Bible teaching go side-by-side in the Indonesian Church. I insist that they bring their Bibles to church, because when I preach I cite directly from the Bible, asking the people to open their Bibles to read the verses that I mention. Then they not only listen, but also participate in the preaching. I also allow them to interrupt, even ask questions during the preaching. In that way the worship will be lively. And we do not have a choir�everybody sings. So we have liturgical congregational singing. Everybody participates.

�How often do the people confess and commune?

�Every time they want to take Communion they have to confess. This may be in another place if they feel that they have a great sin they have to confess, because the priest usually does not have enough time during the service. But the norm is that they confess every time they want to take Communion.

�How do you keep the fasts?

�The diet of Indonesian people is very different from the European or Russian diet. Cheese is not part of our diet. People in the villages usually don�t eat meat very often, and olive oil is not a delicacy for us, so we do not use it. So, if we follow the fast as it is done in Greece, Russia, or America, our people would never fast because their food is always fasting food. But fortunately, I was on Mt. Athos and I saw some monks that sometimes do not eat until the ninth hour or just before Vespers. I got inspiration from that practice, and I told my people that in order for them to feel the fast they should eat vegetarian food, and eat only at the time of the ninth hour or before Vespers. So that�s what we do. We fast on Friday and Wednesday, just like any other Orthodox.

�What problems do the Orthodox people in Indonesia face?

�The problem is economic. It is difficult to get people to convert, but easy to lose them. So far we do not have many people; many young women want to get married and we don�t have many young men in the Church and vice versa, so they find people from outside the faith�either from non-Orthodox Christianity, or some other religion. We lose people through that kind of situation. We also lose people because of the economic situation. They may work in a non-Orthodox institution, and this institution is willing to accept them if they leave the Orthodox Church and join that church. Sometimes there are very unethical denominations. They provide buses and stop in places where there are Orthodox people, or any other Christians, to bring them to that church. In that way we also lose people. The Muslims are also very aggressive now. They also try to convert Christians to Islam. Sometimes we lose people back to Islam. Some churches provide scholarships to the children�especially Pentecostals�with the promise that they will bring their parents to the church. One time we lost a family because of that�because of the money. It�s very painful for us, because we convert people with much difficulty and we lose them through Islamic influence.

�Are there any Indonesian saints?

�No, we do not yet have any saints. Well, there is Father Gregory who was murdered. We do not know who killed him, but we believe it was a Muslim, because when I called his phone, a woman answered and said �As-salamu alaikum.� I consider him to be a martyr, personally. People may not believe that, it�s not officially recognized, but I believe he was killed in the line of duty and that he is a martyr.

�What is the potential for the growth of Orthodoxy in Indonesia?

�Orthodoxy has great potential to grow in Indonesia, if we have enough available information about the faith. Therefore we need more books about Orthodoxy in the Indonesian language. I have written books on various topics, published in the past, but because of a lack of money now they are just sitting as files on my computer. Since I know the mind of the people I can explain things to them in a way they can understand. Just as Byzantine Orthodoxy became Russian Orthodoxy, in the future Russian Orthodoxy will become Indonesian Orthodoxy. We want to be just as the Russians, but as Indonesians. We cannot be other than what we are. And I said before, we hope to build a seminary, monastery, and more churches.

�What is needed to develop the preaching in Indonesia?

�Education, availability of books, a website� In the future we need a local bishop in Indonesia for the ordination of priests, so that we will not have to wait for a foreign bishop to come to us from far away. Also, there is a law that foreign nationals cannot be religious leaders of any kind, and thus we call ourselves the Indonesian Orthodox Church�not the Greek, or Russian, even though we are under the Russian Church.

�You spent time on Mt. Athos at Simenopetra Monastery, and you knew Elder Emelianos. What did you learn from him that you have kept with you in your personal life and in your work with the mission?

�Many things, many things. I always remember his word: ipomoni (?p?�???). �Be patient.� I will never forget that he would always say ipomoni, �be patient.� Learning to be patient is hard for me because I�m a person who is on the go all the time. I�m a doer, and to be patient is not one of my traits, but I have to learn. And that is what I learned from Father Emelianos. Also his openness�he was very open with me in spite of my being the first Indonesian ever to step foot on Mt. Athos. He treated me just like a son, even though at that time I did not speak Greek well�but I was able to understand what he said. Of course I had Fr. Makarios from France, who was helping me translate what he said. So the word that always I remember from Father Amelianos is ipomoni.

�Concerning how people live in Indonesia: What is the difference in worldview or lifestyle between Muslims and Christians?

�I think it is in the way they look, the way they behave. You can tell by the way they talk, the type of language, their choice of words. They differ. And there is separation even in how they clothe themselves. In terms of their general attitude�after all we are Indonesian, so it�s difficult to say.


Dimitry Degtirev interviewed Archimandrite Daniel Byantoro


If anyone would like to help Fr. Daniel and the Orthodox Christians in Indonesia, donations can be sent to the following bank account:

Bank Name: CitiBank
Account number: 8000352267
Name on account: Bambang Dwi Byantoro
CIF number: 627405
Address: Landmark Building
Street: Jalan Jendral Sudirman No. 1
City: Jakarta
Country: Indonesia 12910
Swift Code: CITIIDJX
E-mail address: m2j2pa4it@gmail.com.

Saturday, 16 May 2015

Metropolitan Hilarion: Terrorism And Extremism in the Middle East Continue Growing And Spreading Like a Plague

0 Comments
An illuminating discussion of the deadly threat of Islam to Christians and the civilized world, without ever specifically mentioning Islam. 

Highlights include:

  • "If the whole world now fails to unite against this new terrible epidemic, the consequences may be irretrievable..."
  • "Each country should be concerned by it because sooner or later it will come to its borders too."
  • "Russia is a country which will cope... But Western Europe is not at all ready for it. People are too well-off there, too relaxed."

Pravmir � May 16, 2015

On May 2, 2015, Metropolitan Hilarion as presenter of the Church and the World TV program had as his guest the chairman of the Imperial Orthodox Palestine Society Sergey Stepashin.

Metropolitan Hilarion: Good afternoon, dear brothers and sisters. Christ is Risen! In these Paschal days, the mental eyes of many Orthodox faithful are directed to the Holy Land, the places where our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ lived on earth. Today we will speak about the Holy Land, the Middle East and Palestine with the chairman of the Imperial Orthodox Palestine Society Sergey Stepashin. Good afternoon, Sergey Vadimovich.

S. Stepashin: Good afternoon, Your Eminence.

Metropolitan Hilarion: Christ is risen!

S. Stepashin: He is truly risen!

Among the main tasks of the Imperial Palestine Society is a serious, thorough and sometimes very dangerous work in the Middle East. I may start with Syria as the most problematic region today, as this country is very close to us in its Christian traditions. Today all the peoples in Syria are going through a very difficult period and Christians have proved to be in the most terrible situation.

Recently we have marked the centenary of the Armenian genocide. You know that the Armenian Church has canonized over a million citizens who were killed in the genocide. I believe today we have a full right to say that what is happening in the Middle East, too, is a Christian genocide.


The Imperial Orthodox Palestine Society is doing everything possible for it to give humanitarian aid to all the victims of this terrible tragedy. We have already sent some 12 cargoes to Syria. It is free aid; we have collected it throughout our Russian world. People gave out whatever they could. I would like to thank the Emergency Ministry and the Syrian Airlines for the assistance they gave.

Another important point is that the world community has at last begun speaking about the problems of the Middle East. Especially important today are statements made at international forums including in the UN about the discrimination and persecution against Christians In spite of the fact that international organizations have different attitudes to Russia, we have been heard for the first time and not only on the Geneva and New York platforms. For the first time in the history of the UN Security Council it was on our initiative jointly with the Minister of Foreign Affairs Sergey Lavrov that the problem of the protection of Christianity and the situation of Christians in the Middle East was raised at a meeting of the UN Security Council.

Metropolitan Hilarion: We have been working together with you in this area for many years now. Only a few years ago when we spoke out loud on behalf of our Church about what was happening to Christians in the Middle East, the West preferred not to hear us. I remember speaking at a meeting of the UN Third Committee in New York in which about 150 countries were represented. I cited statistics and facts but got full silence in response and a very clear impression that the Western world did not wish to hear about the tragedy of Christians unfolding before our eyes.

Yes, something has begun really changing of late, and if before only Islamophobia and anti-Semitism were discussed and resolutions only this issue were adopted at international platforms, now the persecution against Christians is discussed for the first time. But it began only after in several Middle East countries the so-called �Arab Spring�, inspired not from within but from outside the Arab world, led in fact to the extermination of Christianity.

Only a little over ten years ago in Iraq there were about one million and a half Christians. Now nobody knows exactly how many of them are left there. Various estimates are given from one to four hundred thousand. Most of the Iraqi Christian were either killed or had to leave their homeland. There are almost no Christians left in Libya, where there used to be about one hundred thousand. Tragic events took place for several years in Egypt. Now we can see what has been going in Syria for already several years, where the so-called opposition (actually uncontrolled bands of militants) with the support of Western countries have systematically wiped out the Christian population and the Christian heritage.

All this is taking place before the eyes of the civilized world. And only after videos of mass executions appeared in the Internet, the persecution against Christians began to be voiced at last in Europe and generally in the West. By that time however, dozens and hundreds of people had been already killed and millions had become roofless. And we can no longer wait and limit ourselves only to talks, for resolute actions are needed here and now.

The humanitarian aid given by the Imperial Orthodox Palestine Society in the Middle East to people who have found themselves in the situation of humanitarian disaster. And the 12 humanitarian convoys sent to Syria at the Society�s initiative have helped many people, not only Christians but Muslims as well.

S. Stepashin: There is still another task before us, which, to be frank, is seriously complicated by the war situation. You know that the decision was made to build a Russian school in Damascus, the first one after 1914. There is an agreement with the leaders of the country and there are resources, but we will see how the situation will develop.

I should say that last year the Syrian leaders decided (as was announced during a meeting with President Assad) to introduce the compulsory study of the Russian language for all the Syrian schoolchildren. I believe such support is very important too. Today we are engaged in broadening the possibilities for Syrian young people to study in our universities. Immediately upon my arrival from Syria, I had meetings with both the minister of education and leaders of major universities including the rector of Moscow University. I believe it is very important.

I would like to once again emphasize however that it is important that we are heard now. It is important that our voice should be increasingly heard at international arenas in the UN, Geneva, New York, Moscow and in the Middle East. In this respect, I would like to thank our Russian Orthodox Church, with which our Society is inseparable, and the Patriarch of Antioch, a courageous man whose brother was captured by bandits and whose fate is still unknown.

It is high time for us all, not only Orthodox people, not only Christians, but all who love their land, who love peace and respect people, to think over these problems.

Metropolitan Hilarion: A few years ago I was asked to receive a delegation of the so-called Syrian opposition, though it is not the Church�s business of course to interfere in political conflicts. I met with these people and had a talk with them. But for a whole hour I could not see who they actually represent and what they can influence. During a single talk I heard various names and the names of various organizations. Now they said they were not linked with the army in any way, now they were a political wing of the so-called Syrian Liberation Army. All in all, it was difficult to understand.

It seems to me that now in the West there is an understanding that it is too risky to stake on little-controllable people. Actually, what is the result of the support that was given to extremist forces in the Middle East? The result is that terrorism and extremist continue growing and spreading in the Middle East like a plague. And the Western world no longer knows what to do.

Not long ago a resolution was adopted concerning exactly the situation of Christians. It was initiated by Russia, the Vatican and Lebanon. It is a timely resolution but it is time to move from words to deeds. We cannot simply limit ourselves to resolutions and a statement of the fact that it is really a Christian genocide. It is one thing to reflect on centenary-old events and it is quite another thing to see a tragedy unfolding before our own eyes. It is difficult to believe that Western powers, who posses powerful arms and a powerful system of surveillance and intelligence, have not enough resources to stop this �black plague�.

S. Stepashin: An example from another plane. This year we mark the 70th anniversary of the Victory of the Soviet people in the Great Patriotic War. Let us remember who it were who led Hitler to power � the same West, the same North American states. Until the Nazi infection had struck the whole Europe, the efforts to unite failed, but eventually they succeeded.

What is going on in Saudi Arabia and Yemen? I do not at all welcome their actions from the point of view of a possible result, but as soon a tight situation developed at the border they immediately united and now have the full support including financial from the USA.

You are quite right � we should work together, first of all, the European countries � France, Germany, Italy, who are the destination of an enormous number of refugees including from Ethiopia. The situation has already spread to it. The military component should be put in action at some time, for sure under a resolution of the UN Security Council, but the most important thing is to stop the support, as it is evident indeed where money, arms and military specialists come from. I have an experience of the first Chechen campaign. I fought in it, and we know who supported it � the same people who, later in 2001, hit the towers in New York.

I would like to stress once again that today we in our focus on Ukraine � our pain, our common disaster because ours are there too � should not ignore the terrible tragedy, the plague that can sweep over the whole world in the 21st century. It is really a satanic plague, I fully agree with you.

Metropolitan Hilarion: That is why the consolidated action of the whole civilized world is so important today.

S. Stepashin: Yes, you met with the Pope of Rome, and our Society�s leader made an official visit to Rome. The Pope supported us both officially and publicly. It is also a good precedent.

Metropolitan Hilarion: The stand taken by the Holy See on such international problems as Ukraine and the Middle East is very close to ours. And here we have no differences in essence.

We are well aware that if the whole world now fails to unite against this new terrible epidemic, the consequences may be irretrievable. First, no Christians may be left in the Middle East. And this will be a real civilizational geopolitical tragedy because the Middle East is the cradle of Christianity, the place where Christians have lived for two thousand years. Secondly, it will open a further access to the whole world for the forces which have already manifested their aggressiveness. I believe each country should be concerned by it because sooner or later it will come to its borders too.

S. Stepashin: Quite right. Perhaps some will disagree with me but Russia is a country which will cope. We are accustomed to cope. We have endured the Caucasus tragedy and held out. But Western Europe is not at all ready for it. People are too well-off there, too relaxed.

I think the awareness of it is coming. First of all in France, where there is now a fairly large number of people who have escaped from other countries, who live and work there and who hold views quite different from Christian ones � just civilized people. You are absolutely right.

We should always seek points of contact rather than division.

Metropolitan Hilarion: Quite right.

S. Stepashin: It is exactly what can bring us seriously together at this stage. It is not accidental that the theme of today�s program in these Paschal days is a serious problem in our world which should be resolved.

Metropolitan Hilarion: Thank you very much, Sergey Vadimovich, for all that you do in the Imperial Orthodox Palestine Society to relieve the situation of those who have found themselves in a critical situation, in the situation of humanitarian disaster in the Middle East.


Wednesday, 6 May 2015

Patriarch Kirill of Moscow concerned by Genocide against Christians, Spread of Islamic Extremism

0 Comments
"What bundle of negative energy will we have in these regions?... These are matters of global order, a global dimension, not only matters for the subject of a settlement of the political situation in the Middle East." �Patriarch Kirill of Moscow and All Russia


via Pope Francis and Patriarch of Moscow concerned about political changes in the world
Vestnik Kavkaza via Pravmir � May 6, 2015

Not long ago, Pope Francis called on Catholics to participate in politics, calling it �one of the highest forms of love, as its aim is taking care of the global welfare.� According to katolik.ru, the Pope also stressed that participation in politics was a kind of martyrdom, as it demanded faithfulness to the ideal of the global welfare and bearing a heavy cross of disappointments and sins. �Can a Catholic be involved in politics? Of course, he should do it. Should a Catholic interfere in politics? He should do it!� the Pope believes.

The Russian Orthodox Church is also concerned about politics. �The system of international relations formed after World War II is going through difficult times. And armed clashes, coups, political crises, and various revolutions are becoming a reality in many countries of the world and a change in the world order which was formed according to the results of World War II,� Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia Kirill says.

Today the Russian Orthodox Church is especially concerned about what is happening in North Africa, the Middle East and in some other countries of Asia and Africa where Christian minorities are exposed to direct persecutions. �The Arab Spring had the sources of the external impulses of its origin in relation to the Arab world. Under pretense of democratization it led to the collapse of the existing political regimes. But, as often happens, the aims of the revolution failed to be achieved.

"Every revolution is a process of replacing elites, as well as redivision of spheres of influence. It means that one elite is replaced by another. This is all right when some positive goals for the nation are achieved. But what if they are not achieved?

"In fact, the events that took place in North Africa and the Middle East are examples of a classic rebellion: destabilization of the situation in the Middle East and North Africa gave rise to violence. As I have already said, the expulsion of Christians from their native land. We are the most vulnerable before the terrible face of extremism and terrorism, that uses the name of Islam as a mask. 

[With respect to His Holiness, the Islamic State and the other jihadi groups are not "using the name of Islam as a mask," but are pure Islam to the core, backing their every move with Koranic citations and appeals to the example of Muhammad. The leader of the Islamic State is even a fiqh scholar, trained in Islamic jurisprudence and followed by growing legions of Muslims precisely for his learned adherence to pure, traditional Islam.]

"The terrorists commit awful, cruel actions, declaring their main aim to be the complete expulsion of Christians from their traditional places of residence. Those actions that are taking place in this region can be called a genocide of the Christian population,� the Patriarch believes.

He said that he used to visit Iraq at the end of the rule of the previous regime: 

�There were 45 Christian churches at that time. There are no churches now. It would be a different matter if we would shut down and make machine-tractor stations, as happened in other places. But they destroyed everything to the foundations, together with manuscripts, frescoes and works of art. 400 Christian churches in Syria have been damaged and destroyed. I ask: who will restore them? Who will give money? And will they? Will they pay any attention to the fact that 400 churches were destroyed? Without any reason, without anything, because someone does not like the fact that the territory of Syria is the historical homeland of the Christian community. The Middle East is the birthplace of Christianity. And all these terrible scenes of destruction of Copts, and then Ethiopians in Libya is a demonstration of force and intimidation, but actually it is a small part of the events that are happening. Because every day people are being killed for their beliefs.�

It seems to the Patriarch that �the large-scale persecutions of Christians from the Middle East region, together with the rapid spread of extremism and terrorism, are a long-term factor of destabilization in the Middle East. Indeed, the reduction of the Christian population breaks the balance and provokes Islamic extremism, because a multi-religious society, which got used to existing in such boundaries and in such dimensions for centuries, is becoming mono-religious, created on a wave of intolerance towards other religions.�

�What is awaiting these societies? What bundle of negative energy will we have in these regions? How will relations with the countries and communities that have been created on the wave of this terrible intolerance develop? These are matters of global order, a global dimension, not only matters for the subject of a settlement of the political situation in the Middle East.�


Tuesday, 5 May 2015

Indonesian Orthodox Mission thrives despite Muslim Death Threats and Persecution

0 Comments
"The whole territory was occupied by angry Moslems, many of whom were armed with knives. They were shouting that they would destroy the church and kill the priest, and they were demanding that we hand him over to them...

"...Despite some difficulties, I must say that the Lord protects the Orthodox, and in the past years there have not been any incidents where our churches have been blown up, or our brothers and sisters massacred..."  � Fr. George Maximov

_______

'IF JESUS IS GOD, LET MY DAUGHTER BE ALIVE!'
Notes about Indonesian Orthodoxy
by Priest George Maximov, Pravoslavie � April 23, 2015
See more articles by Fr. George Maximov...

What is the Crown Princess of Bali doing in an Orthodox church, why do Russians prefer to confess to Indonesians, and why Orthodoxy is a blessing for Indonesia � these and other themes are discussed in the Indonesian notes of Fr. George Maximov.


Jakarta, Indonesia.
The first thing that struck me upon landing in Jakarta was how undeveloped the airport was. You didn't have the familiar electronic information boards�you had to walk up to someone who works there and ask them which baggage belt they were unloading luggage from such-and-such a flight on. I was also amazed at the Indonesian practice of gluing large photographs of themselves onto their carryalls and suitcases, with their telephone number written underneath�apparently they are easier to find in case of loss. But when these suitcases with the portraits of their owners are moving one after the other on the baggage belt, it looks pretty funny.

The city itself is large, but by comparison with, for example, Bangkok, it doesn't produce such a good impression.

I had occasion to serve an all-night vigil in St. Thomas's Church in Jakarta (ROCOR). The rector was an Indonesian, Fr. Boris. When I saw him, I thought that he was hardly over 20, and the thought flashed through my mind: �How could they have ordained such a young man?� It turned out that he was really 38 years old. Asians tend to look younger than their age, but Fr. Boris broke all records in this regard.

Inside St. Thomas Church

An Indigenous Mission

I found Indonesian Orthodoxy very touching, both in this church and in another that I served in. The priests, the servers, the choir, and the parishioners are all Indonesians, mostly former Moslems. No 'white' missionary travelled to them or preached�these Indonesians converted themselves, preach to others themselves, serve themselves, and try to lead a Christian life themselves. St. Nicholas of Japan's preaching was very well organized, so that for the most part he was the only Russian missionary, while the Japanese converts�catechizers and priests�carried out the business of preaching; he only guided them and set them on the right course. It was thought through splendidly. And in Indonesia we see something even more amazing: where there is not one single missionary come from the outside at all to direct and supervise, but where everything is done by the Indonesians themselves.

Among the parishioners one older couple comes to mind�the Crown Princess of Bali and her husband. She converted to Orthodoxy when her husband was in a coma and the doctors did not give him a favorable prognosis. But this grandmother began to pray fervently that the Lord would, if even for a short time, allow him to regain consciousness, so that he would be able to receive baptism and not die unbaptized. And the Lord fulfilled her request and then some: not only did her husband regain consciousness, but he completely recovered. Now they both go to church. When she found out that I was Russian, the Princess shared the news about the fact that they were going to go on a pilgrimage to Russia and were very excited about it.

The Island of Bali

St. Thomas the Apostle Church

St. Thomas the Apostle Church itself was built by a rich Orthodox Indonesian family. After the service, I talked with the mother of the family, Mrs. Christina N, and asked her how they came to convert to Orthodoxy (she has, by the way, eight children). She confessed that they had all been Moslems. Once she was at the beach, and a tragedy happened: some people came up to her and told her that her daughter had just drowned, and they pointed to the place where she had disappeared under the waves. Christina ran there immediately. She went into the water and began to go in the indicated direction. One can just imagine what feelings she experienced, going in search of her child who had just died! And as she was going along, getting deeper into the water with every step, suddenly the thought flashed through her mind: �If Jesus is God, let my daughter be alive!� And a miracle occurred: she spotted her daughter under the water, and when she lifted her up and carried her in to shore, the girl came back to life!

It is no wonder that after this miracle not only Christina, but also her husband and all their children were baptized. They didn't know anything about Orthodoxy, and therefore they became Protestants, as Protestants had long been in Indonesia and were well known to all. Now after her baptism, Christina began to read the Bible. She read it through several times in full�from Genesis to the Apocalypse. And during her reading of the Acts of the Apostles and the epistles, it struck her that the Christian Church had been one, united Church, and that that completely did not apply to the fragmentation that Christina saw among the Protestants. She resolved to find out what had happened to the very first, original Church. And to find this out she set out for the place where it all began�in Jerusalem, in the Holy Land, which was possible thanks to her good financial situation. There she discovered that this Church, founded 20 centuries ago, still exists to this day, and that it is the Orthodox Church. Finding it, Christina convinced her whole family to become Orthodox.

Hiermonk Ioasaph (Tandibilang) with parishioners

Muslim Outrage

As has already been mentioned, Christina and her husband built a church in honor of the Apostle Thomas on their own land in Jakarta. Unfortunately, not everyone liked this�one Moslem organization was outraged by this. It gathered a crowd of its supporters together and sent them to the Orthodox church. The whole territory was occupied by angry Moslems, many of whom were armed with knives. They were shouting that they would destroy the church and kill the priest, and they were demanding that we hand him over to them. Retelling this, Christina said that it was really terrifying.

Glory to God, that time nothing serious happened, and after they had made a lot of noise, the crowd dispersed. But the leader of this organization announced that this was not the end of it, and that they would fight against our Orthodox parish church. However, it so happened that in the course of a year they all died. In their place came other leaders, who had changed their opinion so much, that now this Moslem organization officially rendered protection to the Orthodox parish.

As is well known, Indonesia has the highest concentration of Moslem population in the world, in spite of the fact that, by its constitution, it is a secular state. And this is a country where in several areas there have been hotbeds of tension in the relations between Christians and Moslems in the last years. This cannot but have its effect on Orthodox society, although the latter is still comparatively small.

For example, there was an incidence where an Orthodox priest from abroad came to Indonesia by the invitation of the Indonesian (Orthodox) community in order to help them with preaching and serving, but this evoked a very negative reaction on the part of the local Moslems: they sent threats, and he had to leave the country.

Because of the opposition of Moslem societies, in many regions it is extremely difficult to receive permission to build a church�and even if you receive it, there are cases where afterwards Moslem activists come to the building site and physically hinder the building work, and thus the church is left unbuilt.

But, it needs to be noted that nevertheless, Indonesia is not a country under Sharia law, and moreover there are regions where the majority are non-Moslems. For example, on the island of Bali it is basically Hindus who live there, and in the Province of Papua, Protestants. There are also areas populated by tribes which to the last man confess heathenism.

Despite some difficulties, I must say that the Lord protects the Orthodox, and in the past years there have not been any incidents where our churches have been blown up, or our brothers and sisters massacred, as took place in regard to the Protestants.

Frs. George Maximov and Ioasaph (Tandibilang)

Meeting Hieromonk Ioasaph

The next day I served at Liturgy in the parish of the Holy Equal-to-the-Apostles Prince Vladimir (Moscow Patriarchate). The rector here was Hieromonk Ioasaph (Tandibilang), and helping him was Deacon Basil Manuputi. When I was in Jakarta, the services were still performed in an apartment�we didn't have our own church. The temporary church was situated in the home of one of the parishioners�a widow whose only property was this house. She had thoughts about renting this apartment, but Fr. Ioasaph said to her, �Have faith: as long as you offer your house for the divine services, the Lord will take care of you, so that you will not be in need of money.� She believed, and so it was: all seven years that she offered her house free of charge for the services, her children received very good jobs, so that their salaries were enough to cover her own needs as well. Now Fr. Ioasaph has already built a separate church on land that an old Russian emigr�, Vladimir, who died several years ago, willed for that purpose.

Fr. Ioasaph's manner of preaching made an impression on me. His sermons were in Indonesian, and when I listened to them, I had the strange feeling, that although I didn't understand a word of Fr. Ioasaph's speech, I believed him, because you could only speak the way he spoke, about the truth.

Although his sermons are long, he holds his listeners' attention very well: he has a good feel for timing, he knows how much time he has left. So that the parishioners wouldn't get tired from standing a long time, Fr. Ioasaph introduced the practice of sitting during the sermon. And that, perhaps, is the only difference from what goes on in our Russian churches�Fr. Ioasaph is an expert and zealot of the services according to the Church rules and of the traditions of Russian Orthodoxy, so that, in his parishes, everything is exactly the same as is commonly done, as he was taught in Russia. At that time he had two parishes�in Jakarta and Surabaya, and now Bali has been added.

Looking at Fr. Ioasaph preaching and at the attention that he commands, I was amazed, and wondered whether all Orthodox priests here were such Chrysostoms. It turns out that not all are�only the founder of the mission in Indonesia, Archimandrite Daniel (Bayantoro) and Fr. Ioasaph.

Thanks to such talent, on the evening of the same day that we served Liturgy, Fr. Ioasaph was invited to Deacon Agapit's house (ROCOR) to give a speech in memory of the latter's mother-in-law. Fr. Ioasaph took me with him. Inasmuch as many non-Orthodox people were coming to the memorial, it was necessary to devote a few words in general to the Orthodox understanding of a person's lot beyond the grave, and also to the question of why we pray for the dead (which the Protestants do not do). It is worthy of respect, that Orthodox Indonesians try to use any opportunity for their mission that presents itself.

And so, closer to evening we drove to the place. I thought, �Someone close to these people has died. They are in mourning, and I should look like I am, too.� However, when we arrived, I saw smiling people in a good mood. They didn't look at all like people in mourning, as we understand it. There really were a lot of people there!

Everything began with a pannikhida, which Fr. Boris served, then there was a sermon by Fr. Ioasaph. After that Fr. Agapit gave a short eulogy about the deceased, and then suddenly a cake was brought out and everyone began to sing �Happy Birthday to you.� And then I found out, to my amazement, that the Indonesians had decided to combine the memorial of Fr. Agapit's mother-in-law with his wife's birthday. I looked at what was going on and realized that if you told anyone in Russia about something like this, it would be perceived as blasphemy. But these Indonesians were equally sincere in both the first half of the celebrations and the second. You didn't feel at all as if anything weren't right�it all looked natural, although we, of course, could not even imagine such a thing. That's how important a difference in mentality can be.

Archimandrite Daniel Byantoro
Fr. Ioasaph, too, had been a Moslem. I asked him how he had converted to Christ. He told me that he had always taken religious life seriously, and he had had questions about his faith, for example: why was it necessary to pray exactly five times a day? Why couldn't you translate the Koran into Indonesian, why did the holy text have to be only in Arabic? He posed such questions to the imam and teachers of Islam, but they answered, �Don't ask, just do as it is prescribed.�

�But I didn't want to do something, not knowing why,� confesses Fr. Ioasaph. �And then I began to look at Christians. At first I went to the Protestants, but they couldn't resolve all my questions, either. In addition, I saw some questionable things with the Protestants: praying to guitar accompaniment, dances, etc. I asked myself: is it correct to serve God as if you were at a disco or bar? And then I heard that there was a new religion in Indonesia, where they serve differently, where they perform their prayers in a dignified manner, where the women cover their heads and so on, and I asked, �What religion is that?� They told me that it was Orthodoxy. Then, in 1996, I met with Fr. Daniel (Bayantoro) and asked him many, many questions�two days in a row I questioned him, and he answered everything. And thus I realized that Orthodoxy is the true religion.

I still remember the story Batiushka told me of how he learned to venerate the Mother of God. After his conversion to Orthodoxy he experienced the same thing that all converts from Protestantism do: with his mind he acknowledged the Orthodox teaching on the Mother of God, but in his heart he was indifferent: he never prayed to Her, never venerated (kissed) Her icons, and so forth.

Now when he was getting ready to go to Russia to study at the seminary, he quit his job, sold part of his belongings, and bought a ticket. And, in accordance with the requirements, he had to pass a medical examination and blood and urine screenings. But when he went to find out the results, they told him, �You have a terminal disease in the last stage, and it's unlikely that you will even live a month longer.�

He was thunderstruck. �I came home, locked myself in my room and cried all day and all night, and didn't even eat or drink,� recounted Fr. Ioasaph. �The next day, I suddenly remembered that I had in my breast pocket a small icon of the Mother of God that someone had given to me. And it was as if a voice in my mind said to me, �You have a Mother, you know�beseech Her!� Fr. Ioasaph took out the little icon and began fervently to pray to the Mother of God, that She would save him. And he spent yet another whole day and night in prayer. The next day was Monday, and Fr. Ioasaph left the house to go to the hospital. He was riding in the elevator with an elderly man, who asked him why he was so sad. Fr. Ioasaph told him about his misfortune, and then the stranger invited him to come with him. It turned out that he was the head of a private clinic. There they did blood tests, and the tests did not support the diagnosis that he had received. So after this incident Batiushka acquired sincere love for the Mother of God.

Confessions

In Russia, he studied at Belgorod Seminary, and there he was also ordained. He recalls that when, after his ordination, they sent him off to hear confessions, he asked, �But how will I be able to do that, seeing that I still understand and speak Russian poorly?� One of the priests joked, �Don't worry! Whatever they tell you, just raise your eyes to heaven and say, 'Oy, oy, oy!'

Fr. Ioasaph took this seriously and went over to the analogion. This babushka began to confess to him and said something. Fr. Ioasaph raised his eyes upwards and said, �Oy, oy, oy!�1 The b�bushka looked at him and said, 'What do you mean by �Oy, oy, oy�?

Fr. Ioasaph hearing a confession.
But later�I heard this from Metropolitan John of Belgorod�when the parishioners found out that Fr. Ioasaph didn't understand Russian very well, he became the most popular confessor in the parish. They stood for him in lines longer than for any other of the other priests�lines consisting of those who had given in to the false shame of really confessing their sins, or to lame thoughts like �the priest will tell my confession to other people� or �Fr. So-and-so will be disappointed with me.� It is too bad that not everyone realizes that an open confession�despite this shame and such thoughts�makes the confession sincere and gives a feeling of freedom from sin. In Indonesia some Russians purposely do not go to Fr. Ioasaph for confession, since he now understands Russian very well, but go to other Indonesian priests, confessing to them in Russian, so that they would, without understanding what they heard, then simply read the prayer of absolution. Such a deceitful confession is a confession without confession, in order to simultaneously tell one's sins to the priest, supposedly, but while doing so remain as if they had not been told.

Commuting to Church

When I was in Jakarta, I saw some Russians there put pressure on Fr. Ioasaph, saying that the land that the church was on, which was donated by the emigr� mentioned above, wasn't suitable, because it was situated unbelievably far away, and it would take them too long to get there. Instead of this, they proposed that he sell this land and with the help of some machinations try to get the use of a parcel of land in the center of the city. The matter was totally not doable. Fr. Ioasaph and I went to look at the land, and I purposely noted how much time it took to get there. Then I said to those Russians, �I checked, and it takes an hour to get there.�

They replied, �There you go, you have to be on the road a whole hour!�

I, then, marvelled: �As a matter of fact, I personally also travel an hour to my church in Moscow, in order to get to services. And so do many Muscovites. Why do you, living in Indonesia, a non-Orthodox country, think that the church should be closer to you than to people who live in the capital of Russia?� I think that Fr. Ioasaph did the right thing, that on balance he built the church on the land the he already had in hand, rather than getting involved in some risky venture.

Jurisdictional Challenges

If we return now to the subject of Indonesian Orthodoxy, one sad circumstance needs to be noted, that is, the jurisdictional division, intensified from without. Missions from the Church of Constantinople and from the Russian Church Abroad function in this country, and there are also parishes of the Moscow Patriarchate. And although all the clergy and laity are Orthodox Indonesians, they do not associate with each other, to a large part because of the hostile position of the hierarchs of the Church of Constantinople, who regard only themselves as �canonical,� and stigmatizing all the others as schismatics, and forbidding their faithful to associate with them. All this, of course, is crazy, and is a grave sin, because of which obstacles are arising in the very first steps of Orthodoxy in Indonesia. And what is more, this is not from unbelievers, but from the �Orthodox bosses� across the sea.

Indonesian Culture and Sumatran Beliefs

I also should say something about the sights in Jakarta, or rather, about the most memorable one��Little Indonesia Park.� Within quite a large space there are situated sectors; in each of the sectors buildings and homes have been built in the traditional style of one people or another who have settled in Indonesia. One may look around it all, both from above in a cable car, and below, going into each house and examining the traditional way of life of the given people. It is very well done, and it is unbelievably interesting to take a walk there. You need to reserve a whole day to visit this park. Far less time was at our disposal, so we covered only a small part of it.

Fr. Ioasaph took me to an exposition that presents the culture of the people who live in the Sumatran mountains. Part of the people to this day are pagans, and they have some quite difficult rules of burial. It is regarded as possible to perform the burial only after you bring a large number of cows as an offering to the spirits (I have already forgotten just how many now). There is no way an ordinary family can afford to buy this many cows all at once�it's too expensive. So they labor for a year or sometimes more in order to save up enough money for the performance of the ritual. And all this time the decomposing corpse of the deceased is supposed to remain in the home, alongside the living�including children! For me, this was one of the examples of how evil spirits mock the heathen, who have fallen under their power.

And after carrying out the ritual the burial is performed�they put the remains in a specially hollowed-out crypt in a cliff, and at the entrance to the crypt they put a wooden statue of the deceased, full-length, in his own clothes. If you look at this from far away, it seems as if living people are sitting there, but up close it becomes clear that this is a cemetery.

Frs. George Maximov and Ioasaph (Tandibilang)

In conclusion, I would like to quote Fr. Ioasaph's words, which he spoke to me in answer to a question on the prospects of Orthodoxy in Indonesia:
"I think that Orthodoxy is a blessing for our country. I see that in other Christian confessions a person's life does not change very much for the sake of God. But when people become Orthodox, they change for the better, and this is noticeable to all. So, it isn't hard to say that Orthodox people are different people, because with us, everybody looks not so much at what someone says, as how they lead their life. And people say, 'What should we accept a religion for, if it doesn't change a person's life?' And, glory to God, Orthodoxy gives a person the strength to change, and this is God's blessing for Indonesia.�
_____

[1] Oy, oy, oy!�an eminently Russian exclamation which has no real equivalent in English. It can mean anything from an expression of sympathy: �Oh, dear me!� �Oh, that�s awful!� �Oh, I�m so sorry to hear that!� to acknowledging that something is a serious problem: �Oh! What are we going to do?� to absolutely telling someone off: �What did you do that for?! You shouldn�t have done that!�


 
back to top