Showing posts with label jizya. Show all posts
Showing posts with label jizya. Show all posts

Sunday, 31 May 2015

Islamic Jizya: Fact and Fiction

0 Comments
"Jizya is yet another ugly fact of Islam�add to offensive jihad, imperialism, misogyny, slavery, etc.�one that cannot be whitewashed away, even as the world stands idly by watching its resumption in the twenty-first century."

by Raymond Ibrahim � May 28, 2015

The Return of Jizya


Muslim demands for non-Muslim �infidels� to pay jizya on pain of death are growing, even as the West fluctuates between having no clue what jizya is and thinking that jizya is an example of �tolerance� in Islam.

In the video where the Islamic State slaughters some 30 Christian Ethiopians in Libya last April, the spokesman repeatedly pointed out that payment of jizya (which the impoverished Ethiopian migrant workers could not render, nor the 21 Copts before them) is the only way for Christians around the world to safeguard their lives:

But whoever refuses [to pay jizya] will see nothing from us but the edge of a spear. The men will be killed and the children will be enslaved, and their wealth will be taken as booty. This is the judgment of Allah and His Messenger.

When the Islamic State invaded ancient Christian regions around the Ninevah Plain last June,  it again declared: �We offer them [Assyrian Christians] three choices: Islam; the dhimma contract�involving payment of jizya; if they refuse this they will have nothing but the sword.�

The Islamic State�which most Western politicians ludicrously insist �has nothing to do with Islam��is not alone in calling for jizya from Christian �infidels.�  In 2002, Saudi Sheikh Muhammad bin Abdul Rahman, discussing the Muslim prophet�s prediction that Islam will eventually conquer Rome, said, �We will control the land of the Vatican; we will control Rome and introduce Islam in it. Yes, the Christians . . . will yet pay us the jizya, in humiliation, or they will convert to Islam.�

And in a video recently posted, Sheik �Issam Amira appears giving a sermon in Al Aqsa Mosque where he laments that too many Muslims think jihad is only for defense against aggressors, when in fact Muslims are also obligated to wage offensive jihad against non-Muslims:

When you face your pagan enemy, call them�either to Islam, jizya, or seek Allah�s help and fight them.  Even if they do not fight [or initiate hostilities], fight them!� Fight them!  When?  When they fight you?  No, when they refuse to convert to Islam or refuse to pay jizya�.  Whether they like it or not, we will subjugate them to Allah�s authority.

In short, if the Islamic State is enforcing jizya on �infidels,� demands for its return are on the increase all around the Muslim world.  Put differently, if Abu Shadi, an Egyptian Salfi leader, once declared that Egypt�s Christians �must either convert to Islam, pay jizya, or prepare for war,� Dr. Amani Tawfiq, a female professor at Egypt�s Mansoura University, once said that �If Egypt wants to slowly but surely get out of its economic situation and address poverty in the country, the jizya has to be imposed on the Copts.�



The Doctrine and History of Jizya

A dhimmi paying the jizya. Note the weapons arrayed
against him, should he not fulfill his payment.
So what exactly is jizya?

The word jizya appears in Koran 9:29, in an injunction that should be familiar by now: �Fight those among the People of the Book [Christians and Jews] who do not believe in Allah nor the Last Day, nor forbid what Allah and his Messenger have forbidden, nor embrace the religion of truth, until they pay the jizya with willing submission and feel themselves subdued (emphasis added).�

In the hadith, the Messenger of Allah, Muhammad, regularly calls on Muslims to demand jizya of non-Muslims:  �If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the jizya. If they agree to pay, accept it from them and hold off your hands. If they refuse to pay jizya, seek Allah�s help and fight them.�

The second �righteous caliph,� Omar al-Khattab, reportedly said that any conquered �infidel� who refuses to convert to Islam �must pay the jizya out of humiliation and lowliness. If they refuse this, it is the sword without leniency.�

This theme of non-Muslim degradation appears regularly in the commentaries of Islam�s authorities.  According to the Medieval Islamic Civilization Encyclopedia, Muslim �jurists came to view certain repressive and humiliating aspects of dhimma as de rigueur. Dhimmis [subjugated non-Muslim Christians and Jews] were required to pay the jizya publicly, in broad daylight, with hands turned palm upward, and to receive a smart smack on the forehead or the nape of the neck from the collection officer.�

Some of Islam�s jurists mandated a number of other humiliating rituals at the time of jizya payment, including that the presiding Muslim official slap, choke, and in some cases pull the beard of the paying dhimmi, who might even be required to approach the official on all fours, in bestial fashion.

The root meaning of the Arabic word �jizya� is simply to �repay� or �recompense,� basically to �compensate� for something.  According to the Hans Wehr Dictionary, the standard Arabic-English dictionary, jizya is something that �takes the place� of something else, or �serves instead.�

Simply put, conquered non-Muslims were to purchase their lives, which were otherwise forfeit to their Muslim conquerors, with money. Instead of taking their lives, they took their money.  As one medieval jurist succinctly put it, �their lives and their possessions are only protected by reason of payment of jizya.�

Past and increasingly present, Muslims profited immensely by exacting jizya from conquered peoples.

For instance, Amr bin al-As, the companion of Muhammad who conquered Christian Egypt in the early 640s, tortured and killed any Christian Copt who tried to conceal his wealth. When a Copt inquired of him, �How much jizya are we to pay?� the Islamic hero replied, �If you give me all that you own�from the ground to the ceiling�I will not tell you how much you owe. Instead, you [the Christian Copts] are our treasure chest, so that, if we are in need, you will be in need, and if things are easy for us, they will be easy for you.�

Yet even that was not enough. Caliph Uthman later chided Amr bin al-As because another governor of Egypt had managed to increase the caliphate�s treasury double what Amr had. In the words of Uthman, the �milk camels [Egypt�s Christians, that is] . . . yielded more milk.�  Years later, yet another caliph, Suliman Abdul Malik, wrote to the governor of Egypt advising him �to milk the camel until it gives no more milk, and until it milks blood.�

Little wonder Egypt went from being almost entirely Christian in the seventh century to today having a mere 10%�and steadily dwindling, thanks to ongoing persecution�Christian minority.

Related to the idea of institutionalized jizya is the notion that non-Muslims are fair game to plunder whenever possible.  The jizya entry in the Encyclopaedia of Islam states that �with or without doctrinal justification, arbitrary demands [for money] appeared at times.� Even that medieval traveler, Marco Polo, whose chronicles appear impartial, made an interesting observation concerning the Muslims in Tauris (modern day Iraq) in the thirteenth century:

According to their doctrine [Islam], whatever is stolen or plundered from others of a different faith, is properly taken, and the theft is no crime; whilst those who suffer death or injury by the hands of Christians [during the course of a plunder-driven raid], are considered as martyrs�.  These principles are common to all Saracens [Muslims].

All this is echoed in recent times by the words of  Sheikh Abu Ishaq al-Huwaini, spoken a few years ago, concerning what the Muslim world should do to overcome its economic problems:

If only we can conduct a jihadist invasion at least once a year or if possible twice or three times, then many people on earth would become Muslims. And if anyone prevents our dawa [invitation to conversion] or stands in our way, then we must kill or take them as hostage and confiscate their wealth, women and children. Such battles will fill the pockets of the Mujahid [holy warrior] who can return home with 3 or 4 slaves, 3 or 4 women and 3 or 4 children. This can be a profitable business if you multiply each head by 300 or 400 dirham. This can be like financial shelter whereby a jihadist, in time of financial need, can always sell one of these heads.

So it was for well over a millennium: Muslim rulers and mobs extorted money from �infidels� under their sway as a legitimate way to profit.

Much of this financial fleecing came to an end thanks to direct European intervention. Beginning in the mid-nineteenth century, one Muslim region after another abolished the jizya and gave non-Muslims unprecedented rights�originally to appease Western powers, later in emulation of Western governance. The Ottoman Empire�s Hatt-i Humayun decree of 1856 abolished the jizya in many Ottoman-ruled territories. Elsewhere in the Muslim world, the jizya was gradually abolished wherever Western powers were present.

Today, however, as Muslims reclaim their Islamic heritage�often to the approval and encouragement of a West, now under the spell of �multiculturalism��jizya, whether institutionalized as under the Islamic State, or as a rationale to plunder infidels, is back.

Even in the West, in 2013, a UK Muslim preacher who was receiving more than 25,000 pounds annually in welfare benefits referred to British taxpayers as �slaves,� and explained:  �We take the jizya, which is our haq [Arabic for �right�], anyway. The normal situation by the way is to take money from the kafir [infidel], isn�t it? So this is the normal situation. They give us the money�you work, give us the money, Allahu Akhbar [�Allah is Great�]. We take the money.�


Academic Lies about Jizya

Yet if Muslims�from Islamic State jihadis to Egyptian university professors�know the truth about jizya, the West is today oblivious, thanks to its leading authorities on Islam: Western academics and other �experts� and talking heads.

Consider the following excerpt from John Esposito, director of the Prince Alwaleed Center for Muslim-Christian Understanding at Georgetown University and a widely acknowledged go-to source for anything Islamic:

In many ways, local populations [Christians, Jews, and others] found Muslim rule more flexible and tolerant than that of Byzantium and Persia. Religious communities were free to practice their faith to worship and be governed by their religious leaders and laws in such areas as marriage, divorce, and inheritance. In exchange, they were required to pay tribute, a poll tax (jizya) that entitled them to Muslim protection from outside aggression and exempted them from military service. Thus, they were called the �protected ones� (dhimmi). In effect, this often meant lower taxes, greater local autonomy (emphasis added) �

Despite the almost gushing tone related to Muslim rule, the idea that jizya was extracted in order to buy �Muslim protection from outside aggression� is an outright lie.  Equally false is Esposito�s assertion that jizya was paid to �exempt them [non-Muslims] from military service��as if conquering Muslims would even want or allow their conquered �infidel� subjects to fight alongside them in the name of jihad (holy war against infidels) without first converting to Islam.

Yet these two myths�that jizya was for �Muslim protection from outside aggression� and exemption from military service�are now widely accepted.  In �Nothing �Islamic� About ISIS, Part Two: What the �Jizya� Really Means,� one Hesham A. Hassaballa recycles these fabrications on BeliefNet by quoting Sohaib Sultan, Princeton University�s Muslim chaplain, who concludes: �Thus, jizyah is no more and no less than an exemption tax in lieu of military service and in compensation for the �covenant of protection� (dhimmah) accorded to such citizens by the Islamic state.�

In reality and as demonstrated above via the words of a variety of authoritative Muslims, past and present,  jizya was, and is indeed, protection money�though protection, not from outsiders, as Esposito and others claim, but from surrounding Muslims themselves.  Whether it is the first caliphate from over a millennium ago or whether it is the newest caliphate, the Islamic State, Muslim overlords continue to deem the lives of their �infidel� subjects forfeit unless they purchase it, ransom it with money.  Put differently, the subjugated infidel is a beast to be milked �until it gives no more milk and until it milks blood,� to quote the memorable words of an early caliph.

There is nothing humane, reasonable, or admirable about demands for jizya from conquered non-Muslim minorities, as the academics claim. Jizya is simply extortion money. Its purpose has always been to provide non-Muslims with protection from Muslims: pay up, or else convert to Islam, or else die.

And it is commanded in both the Koran and Hadith, the twin pillars of Islam.  In short, jizya is yet another ugly fact of Islam�add to offensive jihad, imperialism, misogyny, slavery, etc.�one that, distort as they may, the academics cannot whitewash away, even as the world stands idly by watching its resumption in the twenty-first century.


Note: Most quotations not hyperlinked are sourced from Crucified Again: Exposing Islam�s New War on Christians.  Full references can be found there.


Monday, 27 April 2015

Islamic State Warns Those Who Refuse Islam Will Die like Ethiopians in Libya Video

0 Comments

"The latest recording [is] a treatise on persecuting Christians. Using numerous citations from the Koran and the Sunnah (the sayings and actions of Muhammad), along with quotes from a consensus of Islamic scholars, IS labels Christianity a false religion and calls persecution of Christians a 'fundamental' aspect of Islam."

Morning Star News � April 24, 2015

ISTANBUL, Turkey (Morning Star News) � In a video showing the cruel execution of 28 Ethiopian Christians, the militant Sunni terrorist group Islamic State (IS) says persecution of Christians is fundamental to Islam.

In the video released late Sunday night (April 19), IS (formerly the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria) warns that if Christians in the Middle East and elsewhere refuse Islam, they also will be slain. An IS spokesman gives Christians three options � convert to Islam, submit to the rule of Islam and pay the Jizya (tribute) or be killed.

�We say to Christians everywhere, the Islamic State will expand, with Allah�s permission,� a spokesman identified as Sheik Abu Malik Anas An-Nashwan says. �And it will reach you even if you are in fortified strongholds. So whoever enters Islam will have security, and whoever accepts the Dhimmah contract will have security. But whoever refuses will see nothing from us but the edge of a spear. The men will be killed and the children will be enslaved, and their wealth will be taken as booty. This is the judgment of Allah and His Messenger.�

The statement comes after the execution of 28 men identified by IS as, �The worshipers of the cross belonging to the hostile Ethiopian Church.� IS shows the 28 Christians divided into two groups of men being marched to their place of execution with their arms bound behind their backs. One group is held at a coastal area identified as �Wilayat Barqa� (Barqa State) in Libya, and the other is located inland in the desert scrub brush of �Wilayat Fazzan� (Fazzan State), also in Libya.

The men in both groups are lined up and then forced to kneel in the sand. After a man who appears in at least one other IS video gives a statement, the men in the desert are shot in the back of their heads. The video switches seaside, where the men there are pushed down into the sand and their throats are slit. Then all the men are beheaded.

The segment ends with close-ups of the heads of several victims being stacked onto their bodies as blood flows into the sea. Then the screen goes blank, and An-Nashwan appears.

On Tuesday (April 21) the Ethiopian Ministry of Information confirmed the men were Ethiopian migrant workers who were living in Libya. Their identities, if privately known, have not been released. The government ordered a three-day official mourning period, set to conclude today.

The video comes more than two months after IS released a video of the execution of 21 Christians, all but one of them Egyptian, on Feb. 15. The Ethiopians and the Egyptians who were executed on the beach appear to be executed in the same general area.

The latest recording issues what could be termed a treatise on persecuting Christians. Using numerous citations from the two primary sources of Islamic authority, the Koran and the Sunnah (the sayings and actions of Muhammad), along with quotes from a consensus of Islamic scholars, IS labels Christianity a false religion and calls persecution of Christians a �fundamental� aspect of Islam that has fallen out of use in the modern era.

�In the recent past, these rites were absent from the condition of the Muslim Nation. Rather, these rites were the hostages of jurisprudence books and theoretical legal discussions,� An-Nashwan says. Quoting the Koran, he adds, �Allah said, �Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day, and those who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful, and those who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Book. Fight [them] until they give the Jizyah willingly while they are humbled.��

�Whoever does not consider the Jews and Christians to be disbelievers and does not hate them is not a Muslim.� � Islamic scholar Al Islam Ibn-Taymiyyah.

Going further, An-Nashwan quotes numerous religious edicts issued in consensus by Islamic scholars regarding the treatment of Christians and Jews.

�Whoever does not consider the Jews and Christians to be disbelievers and does not hate them is not a Muslim,� An-Nashwan says, quoting Islamic scholar Al Islam Ibn-Taymiyyah. Citing a Hadith (saying or action of Muhammad), An-Nashwan says Muhammad told his followers to be aggressive toward Christians and Jews, declaring, �If you meet Jews or Christians, do not great them in peace.�

The video is similar to previous IS execution videos with one major difference: In a recording that lasts just over 29 minutes, 24 minutes are spent explaining the Islamic version of the life of Jesus Christ, giving an equally inaccurate account of the history of Christianity and justifying persecution of Christians.

In a possible attempt to give credibility to IS claims that �Dhimmi� (non-Muslims living under protected but second-class status) are treated well in Islamic society, several people who identify themselves as Christians in Raqqah, the de facto capital of IS in Syria, are interviewed. All claim they were well treated under IS rule.

�The one who comes to Raqqah (after paying Jizya) does not have to worry, whether he is Christian or even Jewish,� says one man. Another assures his fellow Christians that life is safe for Christians in Dhimmi status, saying, �By Allah, we are happy. We�ve seen security under the Islamic State.�

It is unclear what type of duress, if any, was used against the speakers during the filming of the video in Raqqah.

Islamic State, in the wake of its 2014 push through Syrian and Iraqi, expelled the entire Christian population from several villages and cities in the region. In Iraq�s Nineveh Valley alone, IS threw out more than 15,000 Christian families, according to aid workers in the area. Those expelled reported forced conversions for those who couldn�t escape their respective communities, mostly the sick and elderly.

In addition to forced conversions, those fleeing reported IS fighters seized their property and destroyed or occupied church buildings and monasteries, some of them several hundreds of years old.


If you would like to help persecuted Christians, visit http://morningstarnews.org/resources/aid-agencies/ for a list of organizations that that can orient you on how to get involved.  

If you or your organization would like to help enable Morning Star News to continue raising awareness of persecuted Christians worldwide with original-content reporting, please consider collaborating at http://morningstarnews.org/donate/?   


� 2014 Morning Star News. Articles/photos may be reprinted with credit to Morning Star News. 


Tuesday, 21 April 2015

Islamic State Executes Ethiopian Christians for Not Paying Jizya, or �Tribute�

0 Comments
Two more groups of faithful witnesses to Jesus Christ, who refuse to renounce their Lord and God.

by Raymond Ibrahim, April 19, 2015

The Islamic State has just released another video where it executes more Christians, this time for not paying jizya � the tribute demanded of Christians according to Koran 9:29 in order to live under Islam as Christians.



Two scenes appear in the 29-minute long video.  The first scene consists of a group of Christian Ethiopians dressed all in black, with armed and masked Islamic State members standing behind them.  According to the video, this scene takes place in  the city of Fezzan.  The Ethiopian captives are called �Nationals of the cross, from among nationals of the Ethiopian Church.�




The second scene is of more Christian Ethiopians dressed in orange uniforms and standing on the shores of Barqa � the same area where the 21 Egyptian Christians were reportedly earlier decapitated.  The same masked narrator appears speaking about the �battle between truth and falsehood� and the refusal of these Christians to pay jizya.



The next scene is of the Christians in Fezzan all being executed with gunfire and the Christians in Barqa all being decapitated.

Other scenes include the narrator referencing  the fatwas of medieval jurist Ibn Taymiyya that proclaim all Christians �infidels.�  Abu Malik ibn Ans al-Nashwan, apparently one of the group�s leaders, also appears saying that �The dealings of the Islamic State with Christians under its authority is according to Allah�s Sharia [Islamic law].   Jizya [tribute] is imposed on those who accept, and war on those who resist.�

He added that the Islamic State invited the Christians of Raqqa, Syria to enter Islam, but they refused.   So IS demanded of them payment of jizya and they complied and were permitted to live.  Next follows a scene depicting Christians in Raqqa � according to the video�s claims � saying how �peaceful� life is under the Islamic State, and that the caliphate does not compel them to do anything except pay jizya.

The video shows other scenes and cities under IS� jurisdiction, including pictures of churches in Ninevah and Mosul in Iraq being destroyed purportedly because Christians there refused to pay jizya.


Friday, 27 March 2015

Key Concepts Having Different Meanings for Muslims and Westerners

0 Comments
"All these concepts are defined in ways that promote Islamic Supremacy: freedom is freedom from unbelief; peace is found only in the practice of Islam including the imposition of Sharia law, and more grandly, that on a global scale; tolerance is found in subjugating non-Muslims and equality is only found within the same �band� of the religiously defined social hierarchy."

This is an outstanding article, which peels back the layers of obfuscation, deception (taqiyya) and confusion on the part of Westerners when it comes to Islam. To use another SciFi example, it's as if Captain Kirk and crew have beamed down to a planet where even the famed Star Trek "Universal Translator" can't help us, because key concepts have such radically different meanings for Muslims.

This is a long article, but well worth it for all the insights. Be sure to explore the Footnotes, which expand a great deal further our understanding, and are very helpful. Be sure to also visit the IslamWatch site, as it has many more helpful resources.


Key Concepts Having Different Meanings for Muslims and Westerners
by Jon MC, IslamWatch
Thanks to Bill D.

In this article I shall address four key concepts as generally understood in the free western world and the Islamic world.

My experience when talking to Muslims is that when these (amongst other) words are used we �talk past each other� in that each is trying to convey a different concept to the other. Thus I might just as well have titled the piece �Western concepts misunderstood by Muslims�.

That said, I also have to acknowledge that some Muslim speakers exploit this disconnect in order to �say one thing whilst facing west and another whilst facing east�. In other words they use these �conceptual discrepancies� for the purposes of Taqiya.


Freedom

The Western viewpoint:  In the West �freedom� is used to describe a whole range of things encompassed in civil, political and individual rights.

Perhaps the most succinct definition of �freedom� is that of Thomas Jefferson: �Rightful liberty is unobstructed action according to our will within limits drawn around us by the equal rights of others.�

He went on to say: �I do not add 'within the limits of the law' because law is often [nothing] but the tyrant's will, and always so when it violates the rights of the individual.�

Quite explicit in Jefferson's definition is that all people have equal rights. Implicit also is that all (non-tyrannical) laws must apply equally to all people without exception. (This idea was put in British law as the law acting �indifferently� -as in �without difference� - towards all people.) Jefferson also neatly balances the sometimes contradictory ideas of �freedoms� and �rights� which so bedevil much of modern politics.

Freedoms are generally understood to be things that the government won�t stop you doing, whilst rights are things that the government will help protect for you. In other words the government shouldn�t tell you how to live your life, but at the same time it should ensure that everyone�s rights are being equally protected.

The Islamic viewpoint:  The entry on freedom, or �hurriyya�, in the "Encyclopedia of Islam" describes a state of divine enthralment that bears no resemblance to any Western understanding of freedom as predicated on the workings of the individual conscience, nor does it speak of rights. According to the encyclopedia, Islamic freedom is "the recognition of the essential relationship between God the master and His human slaves who are completely dependent on Him."

Ibn Arabi, a Sufi scholar of note, is cited for having defined freedom as �being perfect slavery to Allah�.

To put it another way, Islamic-style "freedom" is freedom from any form of unbelief (�Khufr�) in Islam.


According to the Pew report (2010) 84% of Egyptians favour the death penalty for apostates from Islam and a slightly greater percentage (90%) favour religious freedom.


Is this a cause for concern?  According to the Pew report (2010) 84% of Egyptians favour the death penalty for apostates from Islam and a slightly greater percentage (90%) favour religious freedom.

To the Western mind this is �double-think�. If you favour killing those who leave your religion, then you don't believe in religious freedom. Conversely, if you believe in religious freedom you don't kill those who leave your religion.

To the Islamic mind there is no contradiction because �religious freedom� is understood to mean the freedom to practice only Islam, in other words �freedom from Khufr� (unbelief in Islam).

Thus, whereas to the Western mind freedom means basically the right to �do what you want�, to the Muslim mind freedom means �the right to fully practice Islam� which in turn means the full implementation of classical Sharia law (including all its discriminatory elements against the non-Muslim, women etc).

Note: many Muslims may well want freedom from their dictatorial rulers too (who often are not very �Islamic� themselves) as seen in the recent unrest (2011) in the Mid. East and the early stages of the �Arab spring�. But this is not to say that what they mean by freedom is what we would naturally assume it to be as has been demonstrated by several of the �Arab Spring� Countries electing Islamist governments who are proving to be at least as repressive as their predecessors and in some cases more so, especially towards non-Muslim minorities.


Peace

Apart from obvious definition of peace being �an absence of conflict [war]�, this is a surprisingly difficult concept to truly pin down from any perspective.

The Western perspective:  The English word �peace� means tranquillity or serenity, silence, freedom from war, freedom from anxiety, a state of harmony and tolerance between people etc.

Tolerance, in its original incarnation was putting up with stuff with which you did not agree, but - and here's the rub - implicit was that all parties shared fundamental attitudes to society.

Thus all Americans (irrespective of their roots) would support �truth, justice and the American way� (and who could argue with Superman!), all Frenchmen would accept the principles of �Liberty, equality and fraternity�. Britain has no such catchy slogan, but perhaps the parallel would be �for Crown and Country�.

Today, however, this view has become altered, though perhaps distorted might be a better choice of word, by the multi-cultural paradigm, which sees plurality in all things as worthy of toleration and celebration � even if what we are supposed to tolerate and celebrate is an ideology antithetical to the Western way of life.

Despite this, I suspect that all people would fundamentally agree that �peace� means people of different races, colours and creeds getting along with each other, with (fundamentally) shared goals and, crucially perhaps, in a state of tranquillity -i.e. a lack of (mutual) fear.

The Islamic viewpoint:  Ibrahim Sulaiman says, "Jihad is not inhumane, despite its necessary violence and bloodshed, its ultimate desire is peace which is protected and enhanced by the rule of [Sharia] law."

Prof. Dr. Mahmoud Zakzouk in his book �On Philosophy Culture and Peace in Islam� (available as pdf) devotes an entire chapter to the �The Islamic concept of Peace�. Clearly I cannot reproduce that here, but he talks about the �path to peace� and the �straight path to peace�. Both are allusions to the prayer said in every Rakat of Salah �Guide us to the straight path. The Way of those on whom You have bestowed Your Grace,� (the Muslims) �not (the way) of those who earned Your Anger� (the Jews) �or of those who went astray� (the Christians). Therefore, underpinning the Professor's view is that 'peace' is only found by following Islam.

MohammedIslam.org states: �In Islam peace is advocated as a divine quality to be pursued in order to achieve the state of felicity that we were in paradise, man's former dwelling .� Thus peace comes from Allah who, so the Koran tells us, �is the enemy of unbelievers� K2:98:99 and whose �hatred of you [non-Muslims] is greater than your hatred of yourselves.� K 4:10. Also K3:85: �If anyone desires a religion other than Islam (submission to Allah), never will it be accepted [by Allah] of him ...�

This begs the question: If Allah hates and is an enemy of non-Muslims and will not accept a religion other than Islam, will he give �peace� to non-Muslims?

The answer must be �no�.

Therefore, the Islamic concept of peace revolves, like freedom, around the practice of Islam and, as a logical corollary, world-peace can only be achieved when Islam is the only religion in the World: �Say to those who disbelieve, if they cease (from unbelief), their past shall be forgiven; but if they return (to unbelief) [i.e. become apostate], the examples of those punished [killed for apostasy] before them have already preceded (as a warning). And fight with them [apostates, non-Muslims] until there is no more Fitnah (disbelief and polytheism) and religion will all be for Allah alone, (in the whole of the world)...� 8:38-39 (Hilali/Khan). Translators interpolations (based on Tafseer) are given in (), mine for clarity in [].

A Muslim can speak of peace and truthfully say from his/her perspective, that �Islam is a religion of peace�, whilst meaning that Islam seeks to bring all people under its dominion and that by violent means.

Is this a cause for concern?  Given that the concepts articulated by the word �peace� are so different, I believe so. It is not that Muslims are (necessarily) being deceptive when they speak of �peace�, it is simply that their conception of what �peace� means and the western concept differ so radically as to be in-congruent.

Nevertheless, it also means that a Muslim can speak of peace and truthfully say from his/her perspective, that �Islam is a religion of peace�, whilst meaning that Islam seeks to bring all people under its dominion and that by violent means.

Put another way: a Muslim can be a sincere �seeker after peace� whilst trying to undermine and overthrow Western Countries that are not fully governed by Sharia Law, even if s/he employs violence to do so.


Tolerance

The Western viewpoint:  This has already been covered in the section on �peace� since I regard it as a prerequisite for peace. But to summarise, western tolerance could be taken as a �live and let live� attitude, coupled with political/legal equality for all.

The Islamic viewpoint:  Despite the claims of some people that Islam is �intolerant�, this is not strictly true.

Throughout history Islam has tolerated minority groups within its domain. Indeed, Islam defines a tolerated (or protected) minority within its society as �dhimmis� who are tolerated under a �dhimmah� (also spelt �dhimma�) which is the treaty that sets the conditions of �dhimmitude� on the minority. Historically, this contract was an explicit document between the minority and the leaders of the Islamic community.

As originally conceived, the concept of dhimmitude was only applicable to Jews and Christians (�people of the book�), and possibly to Zoroastrians and Magians according to some sources, but for pragmatic reasons over time the concept was extended to other non-Muslim groups also.

Latterly, it seems that many if not all non-Muslims existing in Muslim Countries are regarded as �dhimmis� even without a contract � in other words the �dhimmah� is implicit rather than explicit, but the consequences of it still apply. It should be said that being a dhimmi is an improvement over the alternative, that of being a �harbi�{1}. [Footnotes at bottom, not linked within text.]

Thus to understand what tolerance means within Islam, we have to study examples of dhimmah treaties.

The archetypal dhimmah is the �Pact of Umar�{2}.

I do not intend to reproduce it here; but apart from a number of discriminatory conditions, aimed at enforcing the superiority of the Muslims over the dhimmis, or as the Pact preface words it: �conditions that ensured their continued humiliation, degradation and disgrace� it includes a �hostage� clause, this I do reproduce below:

�If we [the non-Muslims] break any of these promises that we set for your benefit against ourselves, then our Dhimmah [promise of protection] is broken and you are allowed to do with us what you are allowed of people of defiance and rebellion.�

This clause exists in several versions, but the key point is the principle that if any dhimmi breaks the rules, all dhimmis become liable for retaliation. Thus all dhimmis are �hostage� for each others' behaviour{3}.

It is also worth noting that �people of defiance and rebellion� are 'fair game' for Muslims and can be killed, raped, enslaved and despoiled with impunity{4}.

You will also note that the conditions of the dhimmah are against the dhimmis � which indicates that even the Muslims who imposed it intended that it was inequitable to the non-Muslims. (So much for the oft-stated canard that Jews and Christians were better treated under Islam than were the Muslims.)

Although in theory the breach of any one of the conditions of the dhimmah could put a person outside the law, in practice not many of the clauses were so used and the rigorousness with which they were enforced depended on the attitude of the various rulers. Thus at times, very few rules were enforced, at others all the rules were.

Within the schools of Islamic jurisprudence the consensus is that any criticism of Islam, Allah, the Koran or Mohammed... rendered the whole dhimmi population liable to being treated as �people of defiance and rebellion�.

A consequence of this was that, in practical terms, the �law� for dhimmis could change with a change in government or even depending on how dyspeptic a ruler (or the Muslim mob) felt on the day. Inevitably this led to great uncertainty and fear within dhimmi communities since they could never be sure how the authorities (or the Muslim mob) would react to a breach (putative or otherwise) of a dhimmah � except that it was usually badly.

Within the schools of fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence) the consensus is that any criticism of Islam, Allah, the Koran or Mohammed or having a sexual relations with a Muslim woman{5}, or killing a Muslim (merely harming in some examples) broke the dhimmah and rendered the whole dhimmi population liable to being treated as �people of defiance and rebellion�.

Furthermore, the dhimmi was expected to pay the �Jizya� (variously translated as a �poll-tax� - though the dhimmi has no political rights- or, more accurately, as a �head tax�). Much has been written about it and whether it was a fair tax or not, on the grounds that non-Muslims are not required to pay �zakat� (the Islamic charitable wealth-tax).

Maududi, a 20th century Islamic scholar writes:

�They [Jews and Christians] should be forced to pay Jizyah in order to put an end to their independence and supremacy so that they should not remain rulers and sovereigns in the land.� (Mawdudi, S. Abul A'la, The Meaning of the Qur'an, 1993 edition), vol 2, page 183. )

Thus Maududi sees the purpose of the jizya as being to impoverish non-Muslims, thus the tax, according to Maududi, is clearly inherently unfair and onerous.

(Furthermore the dhimmis were often also subject to Kharaj and Ushr � land and produce taxes respectively � that often did not apply to Muslims. Thus even in those periods when Jizya was less than Zakat, the overall tax-burden on dhimmis was typically still higher.)

According to AL-HEDAYA Vol. II a Hanafi Sharia manual, the jizya �must be exacted in a mortifying and humiliating manner � [as] a substitute for destruction�. The first part is in accordance with K9:29{6}. The second makes clear that not paying the jizya was also a breach of the dhimmah. In fact, if the jizya was not paid those not paying it were regarded as (active) �harbis�{7}.

Thus we find Ghevond, an 8th century Armenian Christian writing about the jizya levied by the Abbasid rulers as follows: �the whole population of the country, smitten with enormous taxes... some suffered flagellation for being unable to pay exorbitant taxes; others were hanged on gibbets, or crushed under presses; and others were stripped of their clothing...�

Had he been writing in the 14th century he might have spoken about the Janissaries and the devirsme system whereby Christian boys were �levied� as a form of jizya to form the Ottoman Sultan's army, just as their sisters were �levied� to form harems.

Although alluded to earlier it is worth pointing out that dhimmis had no political rights in the Muslim state and few legal rights against Muslims (in some periods no legal rights at all).

All of that said, it must be stated that provided the dhimmis abided by the dhimmah (this is sometimes expressed as �obeyed the laws of Islam�) and paid the jizya, then his/her person, property and freedom to practice religion (provided no �song and dance� was made about it - another condition of the Pact of Umar) was guaranteed.

Implicit here is the idea that the Dhimmi is under an enforced armistice. The payment of the Jizya grants an often literal stay of execution and the Dhimmi is allowed, within strict limits, to go about his./her business. But, as noted, any failure to pay up or any breach of the armistice conditions (the Dhimmah) and the Dhimmi (and often his/her whole community) is liable to be treated as active Harbis once more.

Thus Islam is �tolerant� - provided that the non-Muslim community (theoretically world-wide) abides by the conditions set out by Islam which, as we've seen, are inherently iniquitous.

Muslims who advocate Sharia law for Western Countries are actually advocating that the non-Muslims of those Countries be reduced to a second/third-class status.

Is this a cause for concern?  Given that the concepts articulated by �tolerance� are so different (the modern Western understanding: a �live and let live� attitude along with equal rights in society [legal, political etc.]; compared to the Islamic concept that non-Muslims are only tolerated within the �body-Islamic� if they obey strict rules curtailing freedom of speech and expression{8}, pay a special and often punitive tax and have few or no legal, political and general social rights) then at least we need to be clear about what is meant by �tolerance� when this is spoken of by a Muslim. Again we find incongruence between the concepts expressed by �tolerance� between the Islamic and non-Islamic way of thinking, which can lead to misunderstanding.

This also means that those Muslims who advocate Sharia law for Western Countries are actually advocating that the non-Muslims (including the majority of the native population) of those Countries be reduced to a second/third-class status, as well as expressing continued support for the continuation of that state of affairs within the Islamic world{9}.


Equality

The Western viewpoint:  In recent years the West has made great strides in the promotion of equality. The idea that laws and rights should apply to all people regardless (or in the way old English law put it �indifferently�) to all people, regardless of sex, race, colour, religion, sexual-orientation etc.

We are trying to reach a point where skin-tone, gonads (and how you employ them) etc. are irrelevant to your position in and value to society.

It is certainly true that this is �a work in progress� and there are the inevitable difficulties with balancing different freedoms and rights in particular, but that this is a worthy goal to attain is not disputed (in general) within western society.



The Islamic position:  Islam does not believe in societal equality, on the contrary it is a hierarchical system with the Muslim male at the top, the Muslim female as a second class citizen who, according to Sharia has no political voice{10}, is subservient to men{11} and who is, legally speaking, only half a person{11}. Next in the hierarchy come Muslim slaves, with the same sexual divisions, though it is debatable as to whether a male slave has more rights in some respects than a free-woman. Below that come Dhimmis and then non-Muslim slaves.

Thus Sheikh Muhammed al-Munajjid in the �Islam Q and A forum� writes:

�Those who say that Islam is the religion of equality are lying against Islam. Rather Islam is the religion of justice which means treating equally those who are equal and differentiating between those who are different... Islam does not regard men and women as equal in matters where regarding them as equal would result in injustice to one of them.�

Note that an �injustice� is something that Islam would consider �unlawful� rather than any concept of natural justice, let alone equality, which is why women are obliged to wear hijab/burkha{12} and gays face so much discrimination and persecution{13}.

Despite this, some Muslim apologists claim that Islam promotes equality. However, what seems to be really meant is an (assumed) equity of roles, rights, responsibilities etc.

Thus the Islamic website womeninislam.ws writes:

�In one sense, equality between men and women is possible and reasonable because they are both human, with similar souls, brains, hearts, lungs, limbs, etc. In another sense, equality between men and women is impossible and an absurdity due to their natural differences in physical, mental, emotional and psychological qualities, inclinations and abilities.� [Emphases mine.]

Thus Islam does not regard true equality as something to be striven for, rather it regards it either as an impossibility in many areas of life, a lie against Islam; or at best a concept subsumed by the Islamic concept of lawful and unlawful (halal and haram).

Is this a cause for concern? Again, yes. Islam does not have a sense of equality that crosses gaps such as gender or sexual orientation, on the contrary Islam has a tightly and religiously defined hierarchy of status (Mussalman; Muslima; Muslim slaves, male then female; dhimmi, non-Muslim slaves, harbis). It is true that within each group Islam sees all members of that group as equals{14}, but this is the extent of equality within Islam.

Whilst the West is aware in a generalised sense of Islamic inequality � we've all seen the dutiful, burkha'd Muslima walking 3-4 paces behind hubby and heard the arguments about the Burkha (�Badge of slavery or sign of liberation?� etc.), - we are not really cognisant of how thoroughly stratified Islamic society is, or how �low on the Totem pole� non-Muslims really are in Islamic society.

Thus the Western idea of �equality� (part of the French motto, no less) is also incompatible with the religiously mandated social hierarchy of Islam.


Conclusion

When we consider the actual meanings of �freedom� �peace� �tolerance� and �equality� as articulated by Islam itself, we find that all these concepts are defined in ways that promote Islamic Supremacy: freedom is freedom from unbelief; peace is found only in the practice of Islam including the imposition of Sharia law, and more grandly, that on a global scale; tolerance is found in subjugating non-Muslims and equality is only found within the same �band� of the religiously defined social hierarchy.

Thus the next time you hear a Muslim speaker explaining how �Islam is a religion of peace, freedom, tolerance and equality�; at least you will know what is meant.

Finally please note that the concepts listed above do not comprise an exhaustive list of such differences between Western and Islamic understandings.

---
Footnotes references:

1. �Harbi� is a person/group/Country that is considered to be a member of the Dar-ul-Harb (= world of war) and thus �at war� with Muslims and liable to being killed on sight.

2. The authenticity of this is contested and it is probable that Umar I (the second Caliph) was not the author. However, in its most important parts it mirrors other examples of dhimmahs known. Thus whilst it may not be �authentic� in that it may not have been authored by Umar, it is authentic in that is accurately reflects the sort of conditions imposed on non-Muslim minorities.

3. A modern example of this �hostage mentality� was the attack on a Baghdad Church, Iraq, (Dec. 2010) in �retaliation� for the falsely-alleged kidnap of a Muslim woman in Cairo, Egypt. In the eyes of the Iraqi attackers dhimmis in Egypt had broken their dhimmah and that made dhimmis in Iraq equally liable for the �offence�. Thus dhimmitude (like the Umma) has no geo-political boundaries.

4. There are so many references in the Koran and Ahadith. See for instance Koran 4:3, 4:24, 8:66, 9:5, 9:29, 47:4, 48:18-20, Sura 8 is called �Booty - spoils of war�. Also: Bukhari, Vol.4, Bk 52, No.276; Vol.8, Bk.77, No.600; Vol.1 Bk.8 No.387; Vol.4 Bk.52 No.196. Muslim 8:3432-34 (this hadith says in effect that a harbi's wife can be taken as a sex-slave by a Muslim).

5. This is pure tribalism. An ancient aspect of tribal supremacy was to make sure other tribes could have no access to your females, whilst obtaining access to theirs. Here we have tribalism on a global scale.

6. K9:29 (part): �... pay the Jizyah with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued.�

7. In many ways a dhimmi is regarded as a harbi who, by paying the jizya, �bought off� the threat of attack by the surrounding Muslims for the period covered by the payment. Put this way, the Jizya sounds much like a Mafia style �protection racket� (or vice-versa).



8. Some (many?) Muslims inherently think of non-Muslims as dhimmis at best, thus the enshrining within Dhimmas of the �thou shalt not criticise Islam/the Koran/Mohammed� means that we are breaking the implicit dhimma they think have with us when we criticise Islam. This, in my opinion, explains the element of bafflement that many Muslims seem to have about criticism etc.; the �How dare you attack...� attitude which probably increases their sense of anger, since we have committed two �offences� for the price of one: not only have we been 'nasty' about Islam etc., we've also broken the treaty that guarantees �harmonious� relations - and our freedom from harm. The hostage clause within Dhimmahs also explains, the (apparently) �random� attacks that often occur around the world. (e.g. Burn a Koran in America - kill people in Afghanistan, 2011). However, none of this provides the slightest excuse for the violent way in which some Muslims behave in response to criticism levelled at Islam. Ironically, their behaviour only provides further ammunition for such criticism.

9. It should be realised that if western Countries suggested that they denied Muslims the right to vote, denied them legal representation and made them pay special taxes for example, all for just being Muslim (in other words treated them as dhimmis), that the screams of �Islamophobia� would be shrill, unending and ear-shattering. The irony of this double-think and use of double-standards is quite breath-taking.

10. See Reliance of the traveller: o25.3 - 25.7. The only permissible �rulers� are men, also K4:34; Bukhari Vol.9, Bk.88, No.219;

11. See K2:282, 4:11, 4:34; Bukhari Vol.1,Bk.6:301; Muslim 1:142.

12. The same Sheikh explains why it isn't �lawful� for a women to expose the parts of her body by saying: �A woman�s �awrah includes her entire body. The least that can be said is that she should not uncover anything except her face and hands, and it was said that she should not even uncover that.� The word �awrah� means �pudendum/genitals�, �defect�, �weakness/vulnerability�. Here the meaning is that a woman is regarded as a walking vagina.

13. Evidence for this is widely available from Islamic preachers on the web. All schools of fiqh regard same-sex intercourse is in violation of Islamic law and punishment ranges up to the death penalty (see The Lawful and the Prohibited in Islam, p. 165.), which is specified in Saudi Arabia, Iran, Mauritania, Sudan, and Yemen (ILGA World Legal Survey).


14. Even then �some are more equal than others�. For example a �Hajji� (a person who has been on the Haj) acquires a certain social cache and status, as would a Mujahid. Indeed both Koran and Ahadith make it clear that even amongst the believers in paradise there is still a hierarchy based on how �pious� they have been and the greatest of all Islamic �brownie point� earners for status in 'paradise' is to die whilst piously killing Kaffirs.


Monday, 20 October 2014

Muslims raid, demand jizya from ancient St. Catherine�s Monastery on Sinai

0 Comments
Yet another example of Muslims applying the Quran's commands literally:

Fight against those who believe not in Allah, nor in the Last Day, nor forbid that which has been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger and those who acknowledge not the religion of truth [i.e. Islam] among the people of the Book [Jews and Christians], until they pay the jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued. (Sura 9:29)

via
BEDOUINS ATTACK AND LEVY A TAX ON ST. CATHERINE'S MONASTERY ON SINAI
Pravoslavie � October 14, 2014



The most ancient St. Catherine�s (Katherine�s) Orthodox Monastery situated on the Biblical land of Sinai peninsula has been once again persecuted by Muslim extremists and local authorities, reports the Linga news portal with the reference to Copts Today.

For today Arab islamists, who lead a seminomadic way of life in the Sinai desert, pose the main threat to lives of the monks and condition of the monument of the world architecture.

Specifically, Dr. Iyhab Ramzy, a prominent lawyer, related the following details of the crimes committed by the extremists against the monastery and its monks, to the journalists:

�Recently some residents of Tala district attempted to take the monastery by storm�and eventually they managed to demolish the gate and took two monks hostage. The monks had to submit to the raiders and agreed to pay them a tax in exchange for end to the attacks. Nevertheless, the islamists are still threatening all the clergymen and monks with violence, this time because of the monastery territory that they claim had been illegally occupied�.

The lawyer stresses that in spite of the numerous complaints and appeals the law-enforcement agencies did not react to the existing situation at all, remaining outsiders and, in fact, accomplices of the above-mentioned offences. �The only pseudo-juridical instance in the desert is the Arab tribes� court that has levied a tax of 150,000 Egyptian pounds (about 21,000 USD) on the monks,� notes the expert.


However, according to the lawyer, �the oddities in behavior of the authorities� are not confined to this.

According to the evidence of Ramzy, local autonomous bodies close their eyes on the extremists� calls to obliterate Christianity on Sinai and �to restore justice�, which means returning the Christian settlement Oyun Musa (�Moses springs�) to Muslims� with the reference to the Quranic texts.

�Against the background of all this lawlessness not only are the local officials sitting idle and doing nothing�they are even aggravating the existing situation,� Dr. Iyhab continues. �For example, not long ago the authorities imposed a certain tax upon absolutely all the monastery�s monks. It was done because the monastery had a refectory for pilgrims, which allegedly �served as a source of enrichment.� For the first time in Egyptian history, such a decision was made towards the ascetics who never leave the house of prayer! Ramzy has regarded the actions of the respective agencies as �an attempt to annihilate Christianity in the region,� concluding: �All this leads to the physical destruction of the monastery as such�.

In his interview with the website, a monk from St. Catherine�s Monastery, Hieromonk Gregory, related a more striking demarche of the �Ikhwan� (�of Muslim brotherhood�) authorities against the monastery and its brothers:

�While still under president Morsi, a retired colonel named Ahmad Radjai Atiye brought an action against the monastery. In it he accused us of �encroachments on state land�. It was found that we had �illegally constructed� in 2006 many monastery churches, which in reality date to the time of the Holy Emperor Justinian I (527-565)!

�The local government, dependent on �the Muslim Brothers�, issued 71 decrees for the demolition of the fourth-century�s churches, giving Atiye�s action a chance to get ahead; and so already at the highest level the indictment confirmed the claimant�s lie�.

The clergyman also noted that hearing of this case would take place in November, asking all Orthodox brothers and sisters �to pray hard for preservation of the shrine common to all Christians, the true gem of the peninsula�.


Monday, 8 September 2014

�Everyday Martyrdom�: The Daily Life of Orthodox Christians in the Ottoman Empire

0 Comments
"The de facto position of the Christians in Turkey was a rule of fanatical intolerance, violence and arbitrary acts, utter degradation and disregard of human rights. The Christians had no civil rights, only the status of slaves. They were not members of the state but merely slaves to cruel and inhuman conquerors who had the right at any moment to deprive them of their property, honour or life itself."

by Seraphim Danckaert, Orthodox Christian Network
June 20, 2014


A remarkable book has recently been published: The Church of Constantinople in the 19th Century (Peter Lang, 2013). It�s a massive tome, over 1,000 pages long, originally written in 1904 by Ivan Sokolov, one of the leading Russian Orthodox scholars of Church history at the time. Sokolov enjoyed unprecedented access to the Patriarchal archives in Istanbul, and his book is filled with copious references to documents that are not only unpublished but also unknown even to specialists.

Some other time I�ll post about the remarkable details. For now, I�d like to highlight several paragraphs from the beginning of the book, in which Sokolov is describing the general historical context and day-to-day reality of life for Christians under Ottoman rule. The portrait that emerges may not be entirely unknown to those who have read of the Orthodox Christian martyrs of this period. Yet Sokolov�s account is, in many ways, even more arresting, as it quickly becomes evident that even the �average� believer endured a kind of �everyday martyrdom.�

________
. . . the internal structure of the Patriarchate of Constantinople was like a state within a state, having its own administration and court, de jure freedom to profess its faith, and the right to run its own community affairs. But this is only to look at one side of the position of Christians in the Turkish Empire. The other side was the actual relations between the Christians and the Turkish state whose citizens they were. Here, at first glance, matters did not seem so rosy. 
First of all, Christians were considered by the Turks to be a subject people obliged to pay taxes, a people of no value, causing only feelings of disgust to true believers who treated them with disdain and as they saw fit. To the Turks these people were no more than giaours, dogs or cattle, obliged to feed and serve their conquerors, doomed to eternal slavery.


The subjugated Christians who did not convert to Islam had no right to life, but could save their lives on condition that they paid taxes [the infamous jizya] to their true-believing overlords. Therefore the Christians, shortly after the fall of Byzantium, were burdened with a range of taxes of different sorts. Above all the Roman or Greek �oxen� were obliged to pay a poll tax per head of population which was by way of a ransom for their lives, for the right to exist in a Muslim land. This poll tax was obligatory for all �oxen� except women, children under twelve years of age, feeble old folk, cripples, the blind, slaves, the poor, those who were not able to earn their living, hermit monks, i.e. those whom it was prohibited to kill during a holy war. The poll tax was levied on Christians in varying amounts. Soon after the Turkish victory the rich paid 48 dirgems per year, people of moderate means paid half this amount, and the poor who lived by their own labour paid one quarter or 12 dirgems. There were subsequent and frequent changes to this poll tax. 
It was paid personally by every Christian to his tax collector in a rather demeaning manner. The tax collector would sit and receive the dues, saying: �O enemy of the one and only God, render up your poll tax�, meanwhile striking the Christian on the neck.



[This action (striking the Christian on the neck) of the Muslim overlords when collecting the jizya, documented extensively also by Mark Durie in The Third Choice, symbolizes the execution of the Christian dhimmi, whose life � and that of his entire community � if forfeit if he fails to pay the hated jizya. The symbolism of beheading derives directly from the Quran itself, �The punishment of those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger, and strive with might and main for mischief through the land is: beheading, or crucifixion...� 5:33.]
The tax payer would receive a receipt which he had to carry with him at all times in order to avoid being called upon to pay a second time. 
In addition to the poll tax the Roman and Greek �oxen� had to pay a land tax. This tax took two forms, fixed amount and sliding scale. In the first case the tax was levied on the amount of land under cultivation, and in the second case the harvest was taxed. The �oxen� who still owned land even after the fall of Byzantium paid both types of tax for the right of continued land use, the harvest tax being one dirgem in gold per desyatina of wheat and one saa or pood of wheat yield. In the case of arable land, the payment was five dirgems per desyatina, and of vineyards ten dirgems per desyatina. Land tax as a percentage payment varied between one fifth and one half of the total harvest. Christians living off land rented from Turkish owners had to pay a fixed tithe either in money or in kind to these big landowners. 
Since almost the whole of the Turkish Empire was either in the ownership of the Muslim spiritual leaders and mosques, or divided among the sultan�s associates on a semi-feudal basis, only a small amount of agricultural grade land was left in Christian hands. Notwithstanding, the level of land tax paid by the �oxen� was huge, leaving them only a small proportion of each harvest for their own use. Subsequently the land tax was changed to a tax per acre, which was levied on all produce. Under the first sultans the desyatina was paid only by merchants on turnover and was used by the government to secure the highways.[1] 
The Christians of Roumeli, i.e. the European provinces of Turkey, paid an impossibly heavy tithe in kind which they called �blood tax� (f???? t?? a?�at??), or �sons tribute� (pa?d?�???�a). This tribute undoubtedly existed under Mehmed II, but under Sultan Selim I (1512�1520) and Suleiman I (1520�1566) it was organised and exacted systematically. 
Every five years troops were sent out from the capital to forcibly conscript Christian boys between the ages of 8 and 14 years. The officers carried the sultan�s firman. The demogerontes of the Christian communities had to draw up lists of all the local families, and every father had to indicate how many sons he had and to produce them for the inspectors. The inspectors would take 10 per cent of the Christian children, always the most healthy, handsome, active and strong among them. They would dress them in a special uniform and take them away to Constantinople. Here they were circumcised and converted to Islam, the more able ones were taught foreign languages and kept at court, the others were given a very strict education as vassals of the sultan and his law. Many of these young men would later enter the sultan�s guard, either as foot soldiers or cavalry. 
Finally, Christians paid not only legally required taxes, but ad hoc taxes on the unmarried, the married, or those getting married, as well as material taxes (judicial duties), fines for greater and smaller infractions, customs duties (on import, export, transit and transportation by road), duties payable on meat and wine, on mercantile receipts, stamp duty, taxes on salting, fishing, mining and other industries, and so on. In general the Greek populace was so burdened with various taxes and tithes that they really were little more than draught animals (�oxen�), destined for the most oppressive economic slavery. 
The Christians� legal position, their social and civil status, was no better. This side of their existence had been regulated since the seventh century by an agreement between Caliph Omar and the Christians.[2] The agreement was aimed at demeaning the Christians as much as possible, and consists of a series of astonishing limitations. 
Christians did not have the right to build new churches or renovate ruined churches, they were obliged to allow Muslims to enter their churches at any time of day or night, to keep the doors of their houses open to passing Muslims, to receive them as guests even in the middle of the night and to feed them, not to harbour spies, not to teach their children the Qu�ran, not to make open spectacle of their religion and not to preach it, not to prevent those wishing to convert to Islam from doing so, to respect Muslims and to offer them their seats, not to dress like Muslims, not to use either expressions or names used by Muslims, not to use Muslim saddles on horses, not to carry weapons, not to engrave anything in Arabic on signet rings, not to openly sell wine, to shave their heads at the front, not to change the manner of their clothing under any circumstances or wear girdles round their waists, not to carry or wear crosses or holy books in public, to sound the bells or simandron in the churches only quietly, not to raise their voices in churches when Muslims are present, not to wail at funerals, not to carry palm fronds or sacred images in public, not to carry fire in Muslim districts, not to bury their dead near Muslims, not to take slaves belonging to Muslims, not to look inside a Muslim home, not to build houses higher than Muslim houses, not to beat Muslims, not to purchase captive Muslims, not to take on Muslim servants or employees, not to criticise the Qu�ran, Muhammad or the Islamic faith, not to marry Muslims, to allow Muslims to settle in Christian areas, not to openly keep pigs, to ride only donkeys and mules, to attach beads to their saddles, to wear a stamp on their necks (proof of payment of taxes), when entering the bath house to wear a bell, to sit side saddle, not to sit in seats reserved for respected persons at meetings, not to initiate greetings when meeting Muslims, to give way to Muslims; finally, any agreement is nullified if a Christian should strike a Muslim. In addition, on the basis that a Christian cannot hold a position of authority over a true believer, Muslim law deprived the Christians of the right to occupy any position that might put a Muslim into a position of legal dependence on them. Thus Christians do not have the right to become secretaries or chief clerks, to be guardians of a Muslim, his judge or administrator. Worse still was the fact that Christian witnesses were not allowed to give testimony against Muslims no matter what the circumstances, the injustice, or the numbers of Christians involved. As for political rights for Christians, there was certainly absolutely no possibility of that. 
One cannot help noticing inconsistencies and even contradictions in the rules governing Christians living within the Turkish Empire. In actual fact the Church of Constantinople, which took the place in the Christians� lives of the defeated Orthodox Empire, not only kept its former religious and moral power and grandeur, but acquired new national political rights. The Church became a sort of state within a state, with its patriarch-tsar, with its administration and judiciary, with its civil subjects who were at the same time its spiritual children, with its official language Greek, with its unity established by the Orthodox faith held by the whole Greek or �Romaic� populace, and with clergy exempted from taxes and other obligations. 
Considered in isolation, the Church may have seemed to be in an enviable position. But a glance at the other side of the coin is sufficient to shatter the illusion. One must bear in mind that the Church was a state within a Muslim state, where Christianity, from the point of view of the only source of legislation, the Qu�ran, was no more than a religio licita. The privileges granted to the Church of Constantinople by Mehmed II were not founded on the principle of conscious religious tolerance, neither was it Turkish sympathy that guaranteed the advantages enjoyed by the Christian community as a �state within the state�. On the contrary, everything was conditioned by the government�s political and economic aims, and sprang from its effective inability to act in any other way towards the Christians except in accordance with the various laws of Shari�a. This was categorically absolutist in regard to true believers and to unbelievers, considering the latter, without exception, to be slaves, and preaching total separation from them in religion and in social, domestic and political life, along with legalised hatred towards them, disdain, violence and arbitrariness. 
Thus on the one hand there were the rights or privileges (pronomia) that had been granted by virtue of political expediency and had never been understood by the Muslim public at large, and on the other hand there was a position of slavery legalised by both the divine and human dictates of Islam, something which all true believers could fully identify with and which was much to their advantage. Again, on the one hand there was the �state within the state�, while on the other they squeezed all the juices out of the �oxen� for the benefit of the empire whose citizens they could never be. 
Likewise there was on the one hand a juxtaposition of systematic regulation, bureaucratisation and legislation of the Greek clergy and people, and on the other a complete disregard for them and rejection of their rights in the name of God�s law. It was obvious that one hand was working against the other, that the structure of the Christian community based on irreconcilable principles was unnatural and by its very essence contained the seeds of its own downfall. This is exactly how it turned out. 
The de facto position of the Christians in Turkey was an open and systematic flaunting of the law, a rule of fanatical intolerance, violence and arbitrary acts, utter degradation and disregard of human rights. The Christians had no civil rights, only the status of slaves. They were not members of the state but merely slaves to cruel and inhuman conquerors who had the right at any moment to deprive them of their property, honour or life itself.


[1] Girgas, ????? ???????? ?? ??????? ?? ????????????? ???????, 19�34. 
[2] N. Mednikov, ????????? ?? ?????????? ?? ??????? ?? ????????? ??????? ?? ???????? ??????????, I (Palestine from the Arab Conquest to the Crusades in Arabic Sources, Study I), in ???????????? ???????????? ??????? 50 (Palestinian Orthodox Series 50), St Petersburg, 568�604.


Sunday, 17 August 2014

Mark Durie - �Three Choices� and the bitter harvest of denial

0 Comments
How dissimulation about Islam is fueling genocide in the Middle East

What follows are key excerpts from a lengthy (4000+ words) article by Dr. Mark Durie, whose books Which God? and The Third Choice should be required reading for all Christians, especially for Orthodox Christian hierarchs, pastors and teachers. An orthodox Anglican with practical experience in Christian-Muslim relations in Australia, Dr. Mark Durie is a trusted voice to heed in these dark times.

I strongly recommend reading carefully and absorbing the full article, as well as Dr. Durie's books. For a shorter summary of the article with comment by Jenny Taylor see here.

=======

�Three Choices� and the bitter harvest of denial: How dissimulation about Islam is fueling genocide in the Middle East

In northern Iraq religious genocide is reaching end-game stage.  Islamic State (IS) soldiers, reinforced with military equipment originally supplied by the US, are driving back Kurdish defenders who had been protecting Christians and other religious minorities.  While hundreds of thousands of refugees have been fleeing into Kurdistan, around 40,000 Yazidis and some Christians are trapped on Mount Sinjar, surrounded by IS jihadis.  (Yazidis are Kurdish people whose pre-Christian faith derives from ancient Iranian religious traditions, with overlays and influences from other religions.)...

The IS jihadis are killing the men they capture.  In one recent incident 1500 men were executed in front of their wives and families.  In another incident 13 Yazidi men who refused to convert to Islam had their eyes plucked out, were doused with gasoline and burned alive.  When the men are killed, captured women and children are enslaved to be used for sex, deployed as human shields in battle zones, or sold to be used and abused as their new owners see fit.

The United States has ironically called for greater cooperation.  UN Ambassador, Samantha Power, urged �all parties to the conflict� to allow access to UN relief agencies. She called on Iraqis to �come together� so that Iraq will �get back on the path to a peaceful future� and �prevent ISIL from obliterating Iraq�s vibrant diversity�.

Of course it is not �vibrant diversity� which is being wiped out in Iraq, but men, women and children by their tens of thousands.  This is not about the failure of coexistence, and the problem is not �conflict�. This is not about people who have trouble getting on and who need to somehow make up and �come together�. It is about a well-articulated and well-documented theological worldview hell-bent on dominating �infidels�, if necessary wiping them off the face of the earth, in order to establish the power and grandeur of a radical vision of Islam.  

[...]

These events ought to be sobering to the West, not least because thousands of the IS jihadis were raised and bred in the mosques of Europe, North America and Australia, not to mention the madrassas of nations such as Malaysia, Bangladesh and Indonesia.  Having been formed by the theology of radical Islam in their home societies, would-be jihadis are flocking to Syria and Iraq where they seek victory or martyrdom, killing and raping as they go.

Why is this so?  How did the Arab Spring, hailed by so many armchair western commentators as the next best thing for the Middle East, blossom bright red into a torrent of blood?

Part of the answer is that the West is in the grip of theological illiteracy.  It has stubbornly refused to grasp the implications of a global Islamic revival which has been gaining steam for the best part of a century.  The Islamic Movement looks back to the glory days of conquest as Islam�s finest hour, and seeks to revive Islamic supremacy through jihad and sacrifice.  It longs for a truly Islamic state � the caliphate reborn � and considers jihad to be the God-given means to usher it in.

[...]

When Pope Benedict gave a lecture in Regensburg in 2006, in which he suggested that Islam had been spread by force, the Muslim world erupted in violent protests.

Sheikh �Abdul Aziz al-Sheikh, Grand Mufti of Saudi Arabia, responded with a revealing defence of Islam�s record. Without a glimmer of irony he argued that the Pope was wrong to say Islam had been spread by force, because the infidels had a third choice, apart from death or conversion, namely to �surrender and pay tax, and they will be allowed to remain in their land, observing their religion under the protection of Muslims.�  He claimed that those who read the Qur�an and the Sunna (the example and teaching of Muhammad) will understand the facts. 

The reality unfolding in north Iraq today reveals to the cold light of day exactly what the doctrine of the three choices means for conquered non-Muslims populations, and why the dogma of the �three choices� is no defence against the assertion that Islam was spread by the sword.  

It is crystal clear that IS is not playing by the world�s rules.  It has nothing but contempt for the Geneva Convention.  Its battle tactics are regulated by sheikhs who implement the sharia�s rules of war.  Many of the abuses committed by IS being reported by the international media are taken straight from the pages of Islamic legal textbooks.

Consider IS�s announcement to Christians in northern Iraq:  �We offer them three choices: Islam, the dhimma contract � involving payment of jizya; if they refuse this, they will have nothing but the sword.�  

These words are cobbled together from the pages of Islamic sacred texts.  It was Sa'd b. Mu'adh, a companion of Muhammad, who said of the pagan Meccans �We will give them nothing but the sword� ( A. Guillaume, The Life of Muhammad, OUP 1955 p. 454). Muhammad himself was reported to have said �When you meet your enemies who are polytheists [i.e. they are not Muslims] invite them to three courses of action.  � Invite them to Islam� If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the jizya. � If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah�s help and fight them� (Sahih Muslim. The Book of Jihad and Expedition [Kitab al-Jihad wa�l-Siyar] 3:27:4294).  When the Caliph �Umar attacked Persia, he announced to them �Our Prophet [Muhammad] � has ordered us to fight you till you worship Allah Alone or pay jizya� (Sahih al-Bukhari, The Book of al-Jizya and the Stoppage of War 4:58:3159).  

[...]

This grim fact � that the IS jihadis can ably defend their theology on the basis of Islam�s history and religious traditions � means that it will be no easy task to persuade Muslim clerics and intellectuals to �debunk� them.  Such a strategy, which has been proposed by Peter Leahy, former head of the Australian Army, will be fraught with difficulties.  Debunking would be a whole lot easier if radical ideologies were in fact bunkum.  The problem is, the jihadis hold far too many theological trump cards from the Qur�an and the precedent of Muhammad�s example to be so easily routed on the field of ideas.  Indeed it is the radicals who have become expert at debunking, as their successful global recruiting drive shows.

[Regarding the jizya tax:]  Reports show that IS has been setting jizya so high in both Syria and northern Iraq, and levying it so often, that it cannot be paid.  This gives Christians who wish to stay in their homes but two choices: convert or die.  Most have fled, but some, including those who are too frail or disabled to flee, have had to convert to save themselves.  The fleeing refugees are in a particularly desperate situation, because they are progressively stripped of their belongings by IS checkpoints as they escape.  

There is nothing new here.  Throughout history the jizya has been a heavy imposition for non-Muslims.  Large numbers of Christians converted to Islam in the early centuries of Islamic rule in order to avoid this tax.  Dionysius, a Syrian patriarch writing in the eighth century, reported that the jizya often had to be extracted from Christians by beatings, extortion, torture, rape and killings.  Many fled destitute from town to town after they had sold everything they owned to pay the tax. 

[...]

The grim reality is that the fate of Christians and Yazidis in northern Iraq today all too often matches the stipulations of Islamic textbooks: non-Muslim men are killed, their women and children enslaved, and their property and possessions looted.

It is regrettable that the hard cold reality of Islamic imperialism and the dhimma system have been denied and obscured by scholars.  For example Bernard Lewis claimed that �The dhimma on the whole worked quite well.�  

As part of this obscurantist veil, the true meaning of the words jizya and dhimma have been hidden by scholars.  

Anglican priest Colin Chapman, who was the then Archbishop of Canterbury�s envoy to Al-Azhar University in Cairo, claimed in his widely-ready book Cross and Crescent that Jews and Christians were �protected� and implied that the jizya was paid in compensation for them not doing military service or paying the Muslims� alms tax (zakat).  In reality the main protection afforded to dhimmis is that they can keep their heads away from the sword of jihad, and it was in return for this privilege that the jizya is exacted.  John Esposito similarly claimed that jizya is an �exchange� in return for keeping one�s religion, protection from �outside aggression�, and exemption from military service. 

[I have expressed my own frustration - see here - with similar dissimulations about Islam in the writings of such otherwise rightly-revered Orthodox Christian writers as Fr Alexander Schmemann and Metropolitan Kallistos Ware, whose classic books on the history of the Orthodox Church in places go through bizarre contortions and blatant self-contradictions in order to exonerate Islam from its clear commands to wage war against and subjugate Christians.]

Such dissimulations, also advanced by Muslim apologists, have served to prop up the myth of convivencia and a golden age in which Christians and Muslims lived contentedly side by side under Islamic rule.  

Architects of multiculturalism and advocates of interfaith dialogue have repeatedly promoted this mythical Islamic construct as a model for different religions to flourish side by side in Europe today.  This has gone hand in hand with the claims that European culture owes an unacknowledged debt to Islam, and Islam�s historical record has been misrepresented by hateful, bigoted people.  

In reality Islamic coexistence with conquered Christian populations was always regulated by the conditions of the dhimma, as defined above, under which non-Muslims have no inherent right to life, but had to purchase this right year after year.

[...]

There is a chronic and urgent need for a dialogue of civilizations between Islam and the post-Christian West.  However this dialogue cannot be based upon myths. At the top of the agenda must be the twin institutions of jihad and the dhimma.  It is essential for Western people to emphatically reject and stigmatize these two pillars of Islamic law, and to deplore to Muslims their application both throughout history and in the contemporary world.

One of the effects of enforced cultural blindness and intellectual amnesia is rampant theological illiteracy among Western policy makers. This is now having the direst of consequences for Christians and others in the Middle East.  Those who managed the Western occupation of Iraq were deeply ignorant of the dangers to non-Muslim minorities posed by the Islamic revivalism combined with Western inference, and in particular by the re-establishment of the jihad-dhimma system. They overlooked the fact that re-establishing the dhimma has always been part of the agenda of Islamic revivalist movements.  They did not grasp that jihad war zones always prove especially deadly to non-Muslims, even when the main conflict is between Muslims.

It had also been forgotten that advances in the rights of non-Muslim populations across the Middle East � such as the official dismantling of dhimma laws by the Ottomans in the mid-nineteenth century � were only achieved due to sustained political and military pressure from the Great Powers, and at the cost of suppressing mainstream Islamic dogmas.  Indeed this �humiliation� of Islam is one of the very things the global Islamic revival is supposed to be winding back: this is why the deterioration of the human rights of non-Muslim minorities � from Malaysia to Egypt � has been so marked in recent decades.

Today Islamic revivalist dogmas, which have become deeply entrenched in Muslim communities both throughout the West and in Muslim majority states, eulogize Islam�s glory days, when Christians and other non-Muslims paid jizya to keep their heads. Revivalists look forward to a time when sharia principles, implemented through unfettered jihad, will enforce the view that non-Muslims do not have an inherent right to life, but only a conceded right for which they must compensate Muslims in gold.  We need not be surprised or shocked when young men from around the globe, reared on this poisonous theological cocktail, volunteer for jihad in Syria and Iraq to usher in a longed-for Islamic utopia.  It should not shock us that they have no qualms about shedding non-Muslim blood.

[...]

As long as policy makers continue to seek intellectual solace in calls for �conflict resolution� and �reconciliation�, the vulnerable will continue to be killed, raped and looted in the name of Islamic revivalism.  The lives of tens of thousands of vulnerable and peaceful Christians, Yazidis and others, whose crime is that their religion is unacceptable, now hang in the balance in northern Iraq, while the West sits paralyzed on the side lines, stunned and stupefied by the lies it has told itself for so many years.

This is not to say that reconciliation is unnecessary.  Usama Bin Ladin got it right when he asserted that the doctrine of the three choices is the crux of the West�s problem with Islam: �The West avenges itself against Islam for giving infidels but three options�:

�Our talks with the infidel West and our conflict with them ultimately revolve around one issue � one that demands our total support, with power and determination, with one voice � and it is: �Does Islam, or does it not, force people by the power of the sword to submit to its authority corporeally if not spiritually?� [The answer is:] Yes. There are only three choices in Islam: either willing submission; or payment of the jizya, through physical though not spiritual, submission to the authority of Islam; or the sword � for it is not right to let him [an infidel] live. The matter is summed up for every person alive: Either submit, or live under the suzerainty of Islam, or die.� 

Bin Ladin was right about this, that Islam�s doctrine of three choices, encompassing the theological institutions of jihad and the dhimma, is and must be the central issue for the West in its dialogue with the Islamic world. An understanding of this doctrine and its implications for the human rights of non-Muslims should be a cornerstone of public policy in relation to Islam, both now and in the foreseeable future.  

This will not be an easy or comfortable dialogue, judging from the howls of protest which greeted Pope Benedict�s comparatively mild Regensburg lecture in 2006.  Yet appeasement of howling objectors through conflict-avoidance manoeuvers will bring nothing but grief, as we are seeing in northern Iraq.

According to the �Vicar of Bagdad�, Canon Andrew White, what is needed right now to help non-Muslim victims of Islamic jihadism is three things:  Protection, Provision and Perseverance.  The lie foisted upon the world was that there was nothing non-Muslims needed to be protected from.  

Right now IS�s victims deserve military intervention, food, water, shelter and medical supplies.  Many will need permanent sanctuary outside of their homelands.  

Longer term, much more is needed.  Certainly the will to persevere, because the world is in but the early stages of a (now resumed) centuries-long war with militant Islam, but above all, in order to make sustained progress in the long struggle ahead, we will require a greater appetite for the truth.

=====


Mark Durie is a theologian, human rights activist, pastor of an Anglican church, a Shillman-Ginsburg Writing Fellow at the Middle East Forum, and director of the Institute for Spiritual Awareness. He has published many articles and books on the language and culture of the Acehnese, Christian-Muslim relations and religious freedom. A graduate of the Australian National University and the Australian College of Theology, he has held visiting appointments at the University of Leiden, MIT, UCLA and Stanford, and was elected a Fellow of the Australian Academy of the Humanities in 1992.


 
back to top